Jurgen and the law : $b A statement, with exhibits, of the Court's opinion, and the brief for the defendants on motion to direct an acquittal — John Shaqi
Jurgen and the law : $b A statement, with exhibits, of the Court's opinion, and the brief for the defendants on motion to direct an acquittal
General
Jurgen and the law : $b A statement, with exhibits, of the Court's opinion, and the brief for the defendants on motion to direct an acquittal
Cabell, James Branch, 1879-1958. Jurgen; Pornography -- Law and legislation
But that is not the only motive of the book. It deals also with
aspirations for the unattainable, aspirations which it falls to the
lot of some men to feel,--aspirations whose portrayal finds expression
in books ranging from Goethe’s “Faust” to Sinclair Lewis’s “Babbitt”.
These are things which, to use the words of Magistrate Simpson in
the recent (and still unreported) case of _People_ v. _Seltzer_,
are not “naturally calculated to excite in the susceptible impure
imaginations”. And if we want a moral lesson, we have it, because these
desires are shown to be useless. _The conventional cannot be escaped by
fleeing to sin, for wickedness itself is conventional._
And may we observe in passing that the author, Mr. Cabell, is no
radical? He makes no plea for reform by way of sociological experiment.
Indeed, as expressed in “Beyond Life”, his contempt for sociology has
been condemned by one of the apostles of the new Reign of Science and a
lecturer in the Rand School (Robinson, “The Mind in the Making”, page
208). “What we want”, said Mr. Gradgrind, “are facts”. Mr. Cabell’s
book now under attack deals with things not within the spectrum of the
Gradgrind School,--eternal things which continue whether the world
happens to be of the “New Philosophy” mode of thinking, or to have
returned to the Age of Faith. How well he succeeds with what he has
undertaken is quite another matter; in law it is sufficient that he has
assumed the task. And with this in mind, the following undertakes to
tell what one reader, at least, may think that “_Jurgen_” is about.
Jurgen’s name is “derived from jargon, a confused chattering such as
birds give forth at sunrise” (183).[5] He is a pawnbroker, and he lives
in Poictesme, but it might just as well be Kennaquhair. In his youth
he had been in love with a Lady Dorothy; at forty-four we find him
a pawnbroker, settled down to business, with a wife who has all the
virtues of the good wife; somewhat henpecked, longing, like Sinclair
Lewis’ Babbitt, for he knows not what. He has not the culture of Faust,
he is not a Ph.D.; but, like the doctor of Leipzig whose venturings as
set forth in legend attracted Marlowe and then Goethe, Jurgen yearns
for “the distant land”, where he shall be able “to grasp infinite
nature”. He thinks that he is a “monstrous clever fellow”;--so did
Faust, the learned doctor,--in the end he reaches his salvation through
a return to the routine from whence he came. Like Faust he assumes to
unravel a tangled knot. Life is a riddle, nature is a mystery, justice
has an indefinable basis. The learned man in Goethe’s poem seeks
to find out why these things are so; Mr. Cabell’s hero is a man of
ordinary station, but he, too, pursues the quest.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account