The controversy, which I unintentionally started in my letter in the _Engineering and Mining Journal_ of April 13th last, about the advantages of using either blowers or blowing engines for blast furnaces, does not particularly interest me, with the exception that I have about decided, in my own mind, to use blowing engines where there is much back pressure, and the ordinary up-to-date blower for pyritic or matte smelting where much back pressure should not exist. I fully appreciate the fact that so-called pyritic smelting can be done to a limited extent, even with cold blast. Theoretically, enough oxygen can be sent into the blast furnace, contained in the cold blast, to oxidize both the fuel and the sulphur in an ordinary sulphide charge, but I have not yet learned where a high concentration is being made with unroasted ore and cold blast. I experimented on these lines at different times for three years, during 1896, 1897, and 1898, making a fair concentration with refractory ores, most of which had been roasted. I was myself interested in the profits and as anxious as any one for economy. We tried, for fuel in the blast furnace, coke alone, coke and lignite coal, lignite coal alone, lignite coal and dry wood, coal and green wood, and then coke and green wood, all under different hights of ore burden in the furnace. A description of these experiments would, no doubt, be tiresome to your readers, but I wish to state that the furnace was frozen up several times on account of using too little fuel, when the cold blast would gradually drive nearly all the heat to the top of the furnace, the crucible and between the tuyeres becoming so badly crusted that the furnace had to be cleaned out and blown in again, unless I was called in time to save it by changing the charge and increasing the fuel. We were making high-grade matte under contract, high concentration and small matte fall, which would, no doubt, aggravate matters. After the introduction of hot blast, heated up to between 200 and 300 deg. F., we made the same grade of matte from the same character of ore, with the exception that we then smelted without roasting, and reduced the percentage of fuel consumption, increased the capacity of the furnace, and almost entirely obviated the trouble of cold crucibles and hot tops. I write the above facts, as they speak for themselves.