Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll, Volume I: Including His Answers to the Clergy, His Oration at His Brother's Grave, Etc., Etc.Ingersoll, Robert Green
Religion
Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll, Volume I: Including His Answers to the Clergy, His Oration at His Brother's Grave, Etc., Etc.
Ingersoll, Robert Green
Free thought
If neither matter nor force were created, what evidence have we, then,
of the existence of a power superior to nature? The theologian will
probably reply, "We have law and order, cause and effect, and beside
all this, matter could not have put itself in motion."
Suppose, for the sake of an argument, that there is no being superior
to nature, and that matter and force have existed from eternity. Now
suppose that two atoms should come together, would there be an effect?
Yes. Suppose they came in exactly opposite directions with equal
force, they would be stopped, to say the least. This would be an
effect. If this is so, then you have matter, force and effect without
a being superior to nature. Now suppose that two other atoms, just
like the first two, should come together under precisely the same
circumstances, would not the effect be exactly the same? Yes. Like
causes, producing like effects, is what we mean by law and order. Then
we have matter, force, effect, law and order without a being superior
to nature. Now, we know that every effect must also be a cause, and
that every cause must be an effect. The atoms coming together did
produce an effect, and as every effect must also be a cause, the effect
produced by the collision of the atoms, must, as to something else,
have been a cause. Then we have matter, force, law, order, cause and
effect without a being superior to nature. Nothing is left for the
supernatural but empty space. His throne is a void, and his boasted
realm is without matter, without force, without law, without cause, and
without effect.
But what put all this matter in motion? If matter and force have
existed from eternity, then matter must have always been in motion.
There can be no force without motion. Force is forever active, and
there is, and there can be no cessation. If therefore, matter and
force have existed from eternity, so has motion. In the whole universe
there is not even one atom in a state of rest.
A deity outside of nature exists in nothing, and is nothing. Nature
embraces with infinite arms all matter and all force. That which is
beyond her grasp is destitute of both, and can hardly be worth the
worship and adoration even of a man.
There is but one way to demonstrate the existence of a power
independent of and superior to nature, and that is by breaking, if only
for one moment, the continuity of cause and effect. Pluck from the
endless chain of existence one little link; stop for one instant the
grand procession, and you have shown beyond all contradiction that
nature has a master. Change the fact, just for one second, that matter
attracts matter, and a god appears.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account