Lectures on ancient ethnography and geography, volume 1 (of 2) : $b comprising Greece and her colonies, Epirus, Macedonia, Illyricum, Italy, Gaul, Spain, Britain, the north of Africa, etc.Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
History
Lectures on ancient ethnography and geography, volume 1 (of 2) : $b comprising Greece and her colonies, Epirus, Macedonia, Illyricum, Italy, Gaul, Spain, Britain, the north of Africa, etc.
Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
Ethnology; Geography, Ancient; History, Ancient
[15] This name has been substituted by me from the Iliad, ii. 561,
for one which occurs only in a single set of notes, and is altogether
mis-written.—ED.
[16] Verse 533.
[17] “The part of Laconia, which forms the western coast of the Argolic
gulf, but which, by the division of Philip of Macedonia was restored to
Argos, will be spoken of when I come to describe Laconia.”
[18] “A stadium measures 600 Greek feet, and eight stadia make a Roman
mile; 606 feet and 9 inches English are equal to a stadium. This is a
well known fact, requiring no proof. But it is a very debatable question,
as to whether the ancients, when reckoning by stadia, always adopted
the measure of the Olympian stadium, or whether we have sometimes to
understand others. The latter opinion has been very generally spread
by the moderns, especially in consequence of an error committed by
the excellent D’Anville. It very often occurs, that the distances
mentioned by the ancients are irreconcilable with modern measurements;
whence it has been inferred that sometimes different stadia must be
meant, and the statement that the Pythian stadium was shorter than
the Olympian, appeared to support this supposition. But there is no
other hypothesis which has been set forth equally often, and is yet so
devoid of all foundation: the ancient writers do not furnish a single
passage in support of the assertion; an endless confusion, moreover,
would be introduced into all statements, if we were to suppose that
the ancients reckoned according to different stadia without informing
their readers of it. Wherever the stadia mentioned are irreconcilable
with correct measurements, the cause is no other but either an error in
our calculation, or some inaccuracy in the statements of the ancients,
which arose in a very natural manner; for the high-roads in Greece were,
not like those of the Romans, made in a straight line, but had various
turnings, because they had been gradually formed out of the common paths
across the fields. In some instances, on the other hand, it has been
found that, where the ancients were charged with inaccuracy, too much
confidence has been placed in modern travellers, so that the statements
of the ancients are, after all, not as inaccurate as some have supposed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account