Lectures on the rise and development of medieval architecture; vol. 1Scott, George Gilbert, Sir
History
Lectures on the rise and development of medieval architecture; vol. 1
Scott, George Gilbert, Sir
Architecture, Gothic; Architecture, Medieval
It has for years been a question _sub judice_, whether architectural
foliated carving, etc., ought to represent natural or purely
conventional forms. I am not going to open up this controversy, but I
think it right to urge upon you in your studies to follow up _both_, and
to aid them by careful study of the actual objects of nature which are
suggestive either of one or the other. The period I have recommended as
our central rallying-point was just that at which the two kinds of
foliage were used together and on equal terms. My own opinion is that no
art can be a _living_ one which founds its ornamentation wholly upon a
_bygone conventionalism_. This does not, however, prove that we ought
directly to copy nature as it comes before us. If we demand
conventionalisms, though we _may_ adopt those of our predecessors, we
_ought_ to be able to conventionalise for ourselves.
For my own part, as I equally admire several of the forms of foliated
ornament I find in the range of works I claim as our types, I am content
to use them each in their turn; but I cannot reject _nature_ as the
_great guide_, though the more we are able so far to conventionalise her
productions and to “_bring into service_,” and suit them to the uses to
be made of them, the better will our work be.
In _sculpture_ I hold that we ought to be able to follow what is good
and noble in the form of that art which belonged to the finest period of
our architecture, and yet to unite it with the most perfect art which
can be produced. _Greek_ art unites perfectly with Gothic, but both
demand the spirit and soul of the true artist, aided by the use of what
he sees in actual life. I confess, however, that so little opportunity
is allowed us for cultivating this art in connection with architecture,
and so small the funds at our disposal, that we have fallen into the sin
of putting our sculpture into the hands of men of a very inferior
class--extemporised, in fact, from amongst our ordinary carvers; and the
only wonder to me is, _not_ that they do so badly, but _so well_ as they
do. This is a _noble_ subject on which to follow out a new and higher
aim, and the students of the Royal Academy might especially devote
themselves to its realisation. I fear that we older architects shall not
succeed, but we may claim aid of _you_ who have better opportunities;
and I would, as a help, suggest a course of study from the finest and
purest Greek side by side with the best Gothic sculpture, endeavouring
to unite their qualities, and to add to them what is to be gathered from
the study of nature--not only the usual study of the human figure, but
rather the importing into sculpture touches of nature and fact as they
come before us.
To this also we need to add the study of _animal_ sculpture, a point in
which such artists as we are able to employ are usually, though not
always, equally behind-hand.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account