Parliamentary action is becoming notoriously ineffective. In America
certainly the concentration of power in the Executive is out of
all proportion either to the intentions of the Fathers or to the
orthodox theory of representative government. The cause is fairly
clear. Congress is an assemblage of men selected for local reasons
from districts. It brings to Washington a more or less accurate sense
of the superficial desires of its constituency. In Washington it is
supposed to think nationally and internationally. But for that task
its equipment and its sources of information are hardly better than
that of any other reader of the newspaper. Except for its spasmodic
investigating committees, Congress has no particular way of informing
itself. But the Executive has. The Executive is an elaborate hierarchy
reaching to every part of the nation and to all parts of the world.
It has an independent machinery, fallible and not too truthworthy,
of course, but nevertheless a machinery of intelligence. It can be
informed and it can act, whereas Congress is not informed and cannot
act.
Now the popular theory of representative government is that the
representatives have the information and therefore create the policy
which the executive administers. The more subtle theory is that the
executive initiates the policy which the legislature corrects in
accordance with popular wisdom. But when the legislature is haphazardly
informed, this amounts to very little, and the people themselves prefer
to trust the executive which knows, rather than the Congress which is
vainly trying to know. The result has been the development of a kind
of government which has been harshly described as plebiscite autocracy,
or government by newspapers. Decisions in the modern state tend to be
made by the interaction, not of Congress and the executive, but of
public opinion and the executive.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account