Liberty in the modern stateLaski, Harold J. (Harold Joseph)
Science
Liberty in the modern state
Laski, Harold J. (Harold Joseph)
Liberty; Political science
Here, I think, it is relevant to say a word upon one special aspect of
freedom of expression for printed matter. I have argued that no limit
of any kind is to be placed upon it, at any rate in normal times. The
book, the pamphlet, the newspaper, ought to circulate with unimpeded
freedom in whatever direction they can move. Many people who sympathize
with this view will, however, except from this freedom printed
material which is addressed to the armed forces of the state; and most
governments, of course, have special legislation, with specially severe
penalties, against any attempt at interference with their loyalty. I
cannot myself see that this exception is justified. The armed forces
of the state consist of citizens. The government has quite exceptional
opportunities to retain their allegiance. If a printed document is able
to sow disaffection amongst them, there must be something very wrong
with the government. And, in fact, whenever agitation has produced
military or naval disloyalty that has been the outcome not of affection
for the principles upon which the agitators lay emphasis, but of
grievances which have made either soldiers or sailors responsive to a
plea for their disloyalty. That was the case with the Spithead mutinies
of 1797; with the French troops in 1789; with the Russian troops in
1917. If the army or the navy is prepared to turn upon the government,
the likelihood is great that the government is unfit to retain power.
For anyone who can disturb the allegiance of a mind as trained to
obedience as that of the soldier or the sailor has, I believe, an _a
priori_ case for insisting that his particular philosophy corresponds
to an urgent human need.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account