Acharius[703] included them among the lichen structures which he called “cephalodia”: he described them as very minute tubercles rising up from the substance of the thallus and projecting somewhat above it. He also figures a section through two “cephalodia” of _Physcia ciliaris_. Fries[704] looked on them as being mostly “anamorphoses of apothecia, the presence of abortive fruits transforming the angiocarpous lichen to the appearance of a gymnocarpous form.” Wallroth[705] assigned the small black fruits to the comprehensive fungus genus _Sphaeria_ or classified lichens bearing spermogonia only as distinct genera and species (_Pyrenothea_ and _Thrombium_). Later students of lichens—Schaerer[706], Flotow[707], and others—accepted Wallroth’s interpretation of their relation to the thallus, or they ignored them altogether in their descriptions of species. B. SPERMOGONIA AS MALE ORGANS Interest in these minute “tubercles” and their enclosed “corpuscles” was revived by Itzigsohn[708] who examined them with an improved microscope. He macerated in water during a few days that part of the thallus on which they were developed, and, at the end of the time, discovered that the solution contained large numbers of motile bodies which he naturally took to be the corpuscles from the broken down tubercles. He claimed to have established their function as male motile cells or spermatozoa. The discovery seemed not only to prove their sexual nature, but to link up the reproduction of lichens with that of the higher cryptogams. The tubercles in which the “spermatozoa” were produced he designated as antheridia. More prolonged maceration of the tissue to the very verge of decay yielded still larger numbers of the “spermatozoa” which we now recognize to have been motile bacilli. Tulasne[709] next took up the subject, and failing to find the motile cells, he wrongly insisted that Itzigsohn had been misled by mere Brownian movement, but at the same time he accepted the theory that the minute conceptacles were spermogonia or male organs of lichens. He also pointed out that their constant occurrence on the thallus of practically every species of lichen, and their definite form, though with considerable variation, rendered it impossible to regard them as accidental or of no importance to the life of the plant. He compared them with fungal pycnidia such as _Phyllosticta_ or _Septoria_ which outwardly they resembled, but whereas the pycnidial spores germinated freely, the spermatia of the spermogonia, as far as his experience went, were incapable of germination. C. OCCURRENCE AND DISTRIBUTION