This distinction agrees with the fact of the diffusion of life. Life
does not belong to the superior animals alone, and to the man in whom
we can recognize a reasoning soul. It is extended to the vast multitude
of humbler beings to which such lofty faculties cannot be attributed,
the invertebrates, microscopic animals, and plants. The advantage is
compensated for by the inconvenience of breaking down all continuity
between the soul and life; a continuity which is the principle of the
two other doctrines, animism and monism, and which is, we may say, the
very aim and the unquestionable tendency of science.
As for classical philosophy, it satisfies the necessity of establishing
the unity of the living being,—_i.e._, of bringing into harmony soul
and body,—but in a manner which we need not here discuss. It attributes
to the soul several modalities, several distinct powers: powers of
the vegetative life, powers of the sensitive life, and powers of the
intellectual life. And this other solution of the problem would be, in
the opinion of M. Gardair, in complete agreement with the doctrines of
St. Thomas Aquinas.
§ 1. THE VITALISM OF BARTHEZ: ITS EXTENSION.
Vitalism reached its most perfect expression in the second half
of the eighteenth century in the hands of the representatives of
the Montpellier school—Bordeu, Grimaud, and Barthez. The last, in
particular, contributed to the prevalence of the doctrine in medical
circles. A man of profound erudition, a collaborates with d’Alembert
in the _Encyclopædia_, he exercised quite a preponderant influence
on the medicine of his day. Stationed at Paris during part of his
career, physician to the King and the Duke of Orleans, we may say
that he supported his theories by every imaginable influence which
might contribute to their success. In consequence of this, the medical
schools taught that vital phenomena are the immediate effects of a
force which has no analogues outside the living body. This conception
reigned unchallenged up to the days of Bichat.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account