On the threshold of this new science we find inscribed _the principle
of the conservation of energy_, which has been presented to us by
some as Nature’s supreme law, and which we may say dominates natural
philosophy. Its discovery marked a new era and accomplished a profound
revolution in our conception of the universe. It is due to a doctor,
Robert Mayer, who practised in a little town in Wurtemberg, and who
formulated the new principle in 1842, and afterwards developed its
consequences in a series of publications between 1845 and 1851. They
remained almost unknown until Helmholtz, in his celebrated memoir on
the conservation of force, brought them to light and gave them the
importance they deserved. From that time forward the name of the doctor
of Heilbronn, until then obscure, has taken its place among the most
honoured names in the history of science.[5]
[5] Mayer’s claim to fame has been disputed. A Scotch physicist, P.
G. Tait, has investigated the history of the law of the conservation
of energy, which is the history of the idea of energy. The conception
has taken time to penetrate the human mind, but its experimental proof
is of recent date. P. G. Tait finds an almost complete expression
of the law of the conservation of energy in Newton’s third law of
motion—namely, “the law of the equality of action and reaction,” or
rather, in the second explanation which Newton gave of that law. In
fact, it was from this law that Helmholtz deduced it in 1847. He
showed that the law of the equality of action and reaction, considered
as a law of nature, involved the impossibility of perpetual motion,
and the impossibility of perpetual motion is, in another form, the
conservation of energy.
At a meeting of the Academy of Science, at Berlin, 28th March 1878,
Du Bois-Reymond violently attacked Tait’s contention. The honour
of having been the first to conceive of the idea of energy and
conservation was awarded to Leibniz. Newton had no right to it, for
he appealed to divine intervention to set the planetary system on its
path when disturbed by accumulated perturbations. On the other hand,
Colding claims to have drawn his knowledge of the law of conservation
from d’Alembert’s principle. Whatever may be the theoretical
foundations of this law, we are here dealing with its experimental
proof. According to Tait, the proof can no more be attributed to R.
Mayer than to Seguin. The real modern authors of the principle of the
conservation of energy, who gave an experimental proof of it, are
Colding, of Copenhagen, and Joule, of Manchester.
As for _energetics_, of which thermodynamics is only a section, it is
agreed that even if it cannot forthwith absorb mechanics, astronomy,
physics, chemistry, and physiology, and build up that general science
which will be in the future the one and only science of nature, it
furnishes a preparation for that ideal state, and is a first step in
the ascent to definite progress.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account