Life and Letters of Charles Darwin — Volume 2Darwin, Charles
Science
Life and Letters of Charles Darwin — Volume 2
Darwin, Charles
Darwin, Charles, 1809-1882; Naturalists -- Great Britain -- Biography; Naturalists -- Great Britain -- Correspondence
Every note which you have sent me has interested me much. Pray thank
Lady Lyell for her remark. In the chapters she refers to, I was unable
to modify the passage in accordance with your suggestion; but in the
final chapter I have modified three or four. Kingsley, in a note (The
letter is given below) to me, had a capital paragraph on such notions
as mine being NOT opposed to a high conception of the Deity. I have
inserted it as an extract from a letter to me from a celebrated author
and divine. I have put in about nascent organs. I had the greatest
difficulty in partially making out Sedgwick's letter, and I dare say I
did greatly underrate its clearness. Do what I could, I fear I shall
be greatly abused. In answer to Sedgwick's remark that my book would be
"mischievous," I asked him whether truth can be known except by being
victorious over all attacks. But it is no use. H.C. Watson tells me that
one zoologist says he will read my book, "but I will never believe it."
What a spirit to read any book in! Crawford writes to me that his notice
(John Crawford, orientalist, ethnologist, etc., 1783-1868. The review
appeared in the "Examiner", and, though hostile, is free from bigotry,
as the following citation will show: "We cannot help saying that piety
must be fastidious indeed that objects to a theory the tendency of which
is to show that all organic beings, man included, are in a perpetual
progress of amelioration, and that is expounded in the reverential
language which we have quoted.") will be hostile, but that "he will
not calumniate the author." He says he has read my book, "at least such
parts as he could understand." He sent me some notes and suggestions
(quite unimportant), and they show me that I have unavoidably done
harm to the subject, by publishing an abstract. He is a real Pallasian;
nearly all our domestic races descended from a multitude of wild species
now commingled. I expected Murchison to be outrageous. How little he
could ever have grappled with the subject of denudation! How singular
so great a geologist should have so unphilosophical a mind! I have had
several notes from --, very civil and less decided. Says he shall not
pronounce against me without much reflection, PERHAPS WILL SAY NOTHING
on the subject. X. says -- will go to that part of hell, which Dante
tells us is appointed for those who are neither on God's side nor on
that of the devil.
I fully believe that I owe the comfort of the next few years of my life
to your generous support, and that of a very few others. I do not think
I am brave enough to have stood being odious without support; now I feel
as bold as a lion. But there is one thing I can see I must learn, viz.,
to think less of myself and my book. Farewell, with cordial thanks.
Yours most truly, C. DARWIN.
I return home on the 7th, and shall sleep at Erasmus's. I will call on
you about ten o'clock, on Thursday, the 8th, and sit with you, as I have
so often sat, during your breakfast.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account