Life and works of Alexander Csoma de Körös : $b A biography compiled chiefly from hitherto unpublished dataDuka, Tivadar
History
Life and works of Alexander Csoma de Körös : $b A biography compiled chiefly from hitherto unpublished data
Duka, Tivadar
Kőrösi Csoma, Sándor, 1784-1842
Critics do not omit to mention, that Csoma was quite ignorant of
Sanskrit whilst engaged in his Tibetan studies. It is quite true that
when, in 1822, he travelled through Kashmir, and reached Leh, intending
to penetrate by way of Yarkand to the borders of China, and there to
become acquainted with the Mongolian languages, he thought that these
latter would serve his purpose better than any other. He certainly was
not then a master of Sanskrit, his original or final aim of research
not being India, but China, especially Mongolia. But when he seriously
commenced the study of Tibetan, and had also come across numerous
elementary Sanskrit and Tibetan works, of which we find special mention
in his writings, can it be reasonably supposed, that the ever-eager and
indefatigable student, would have neglected such opportunities as
presented themselves to him, and have remained entirely ignorant of the
Sanskrit language for so many years, which, as he tells us at the
outset of his new study, was the basis of all Tibetan learning? So far
from this being the case, his letters to Captain Kennedy furnish ample
proofs to the contrary. For instance, in his second letter to Captain
Kennedy, para. 12, we read as follows:—“Besides the vocabulary which I
have now by me, ... I have another large collection of words in
Sanskrit and Tibetan.” This clearly establishes our surmise, that long
before 1825 Csoma devoted serious attention to Sanskrit; indeed, how
otherwise could he have written his report of 1825 to Government,
through Captain Kennedy?
Csoma’s principal trait of character was his regrettable
diffidence—almost, we might say, an overstrained vaunting of
ignorance—and his own too modest estimate of himself. This has often
served as justification for disparaging his unique accomplishments. Of
this, Prinsep, Gerard, and Campbell bear frequent testimony; and even
Henry Torrens, who knew him less than those just mentioned, notices
that “Csoma’s exceeding diffidence, on subjects on which he might have
dictated to the learned world of Europe and Asia, was the most
surprising trait in him.” [14] Under these circumstances, to avoid
misunderstanding and to correct false impressions which have prevailed,
it seems necessary that, instead of mere extracts, we should lay before
our readers some of the correspondence and other documents without
curtailment.
In November 1824, our traveller appeared on the north-west frontier of
the British possessions, and reported his arrival to Captain Kennedy,
the commanding officer at Sabathú. The correspondence which passed at
that time between the authorities and the traveller is of much
interest.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account