Life of Sir William Wallace of Elderslie, Vol. 1 (of 2)Carrick, John D. (John Donald)
History
Life of Sir William Wallace of Elderslie, Vol. 1 (of 2)
Carrick, John D. (John Donald)
Wallace, William, Sir, -1305
“The story of the destruction of these buildings, and of the immediate
reason of it, is supported by the universal tradition of the country to
this day; and local tradition is often entitled to more regard than is
given to it by the fastidiousness of the learned. Whatever allowances
it may be necessary to make for subsequent exaggeration, it is not
easily conceivable, that an event should be connected with a particular
spot, during a succession of ages, without some foundation.
“Sir D. Dalrymple deems this story ‘inconsistent with probability.’
He objects to it, because it is said, ‘that Wallace, accompanied by
Sir John Graham, Sir John Menteth, and Alexander Scrymgeour, constable
of Dundee, went into the west of Scotland, to chastise the men of
Galloway, who had espoused the part of the Comyns, and of the English;’
and that, ‘_on the 28th August 1298_, they set fire to some granaries
in the neighbourhood of Ayr, and burned the English cantoned in
them.’--Annals, I. 255, N. Here he refers to the relations of Arnold
Blair and to Major, and produces three objections to the narrative. One
of these is, that ‘Comyn, the younger of Badenoch, was the only man
of the name of Comyn who had any interest in Galloway; and he was at
that time of Wallace’s party. The other two are; that ‘Sir John Graham
could have no share in the enterprise, for he was killed at Falkirk,
22d July 1298;’ and that ‘it is not probable that Wallace would have
undertaken such an enterprise immediately after the discomfiture at
Falkirk.’ Although it had been said by mistake, that Graham and Comyn
were present, this could not invalidate the whole relation, for we
often find that leading facts are faithfully narrated in a history,
when there are considerable mistakes as to the persons said to have
been engaged.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account