If from the man we turn to his works, we are struck at once with two
singular contrasts. The first of them is this. The distinction between
ancient and modern art is sometimes said, and perhaps truly, to consist
in the simple bareness of the imaginative conceptions which we find in
ancient art, and the comparatively complex clothing in which all modern
creations are embodied. If we adopt this distinction, Milton seems in
some sort ancient, and in some sort modern. Nothing is so simple as the
subject-matter of his works. The two greatest of his creations, the
character of Satan and the character of Eve, are two of the simplest—the
latter probably the very simplest—in the whole field of literature. On
this side Milton’s art is classical. On the other hand, in no writer
is the imagery more profuse, the illustrations more various, the dress
altogether more splendid. And in this respect the style of his art seems
romantic and modern. In real truth, however, it is only ancient art in a
modern disguise. The dress is a mere dress, and can be stripped off when
we will. We all of us do perhaps in memory strip it off for ourselves.
Notwithstanding the lavish adornments with which her image is presented,
the character of Eve is still the simplest sort of feminine essence—the
pure embodiment of that inner nature, which we believe and hope that
women have. The character of Satan, though it is not so easily described,
has nearly as few elements in it. The most purely modern conceptions will
not bear to be unclothed in this matter. Their romantic garment clings
inseparably to them. Hamlet and Lear are not to be thought of except as
complex characters, with very involved and complicated embodiments. They
are as difficult to draw out in words as the common characters of life
are; that of Hamlet, perhaps, is more so. If we make it, as perhaps we
should, the characteristic of modern and romantic art that it presents
us with creations which we cannot think of or delineate except as very
varied, and, so to say, circumstantial, we must not rank Milton among
the masters of romantic art. And without involving the subject in the
troubled sea of an old controversy, we may say that the most striking of
the poetical peculiarities of Milton is the bare simplicity of his ideas,
and the rich abundance of his illustrations.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account