This was a great step in political philosophy—though it _now_ seems the
events of 1848 have taught thinking persons (I fancy) further. They
have enabled us to say that of all these circumstances so affecting
political problems, by far and out of all question the most important is
_national character_. In that year the same experiment—the experiment,
as its friends say, of Liberal and Constitutional Government—as its
enemies say, of Anarchy and Revolution—was tried in every nation of
Europe—with what varying futures and differing results! The effect
has been to teach men—not only speculatively to know, but practically
to feel, that no absurdity is so great as to imagine the same species
of institutions suitable or possible for Scotchmen and Sicilians, for
Germans and Frenchmen, for the English and the Neapolitans. With a
well-balanced national character (we now know) liberty is a stable thing.
A really practical people will work in political business, as in private
business, almost the absurdest, the feeblest, the most inconsistent
set of imaginable regulations. Similarly, or rather reversely, the
best institutions will not keep right a nation that _will_ go wrong.
Paper is but paper, and no virtue is to be discovered in it to retain
within due boundaries the undisciplined passions of those who have
never set themselves seriously to restrain them. In a word—as people
of ‘large roundabout common-sense’ will (as a rule) somehow get on in
life—(no matter what their circumstances or their fortune)—so a nation
which applies good judgment, forbearance, a rational and compromising
habit to the management of free institutions, will certainly succeed;
while the more eminently gifted national character will but be a source
and germ of endless and disastrous failure, if, with whatever other
eminent qualities, it be deficient in these plain, solid, and essential
requisites.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account