think of going for ethics and æsthetics to the bigamy of Lamech, or the
musical accomplishments of Tubal Cain. If the Comte de Chambord be (as it
is quite on the cards that he may be), within a few years restored, he
must govern by the instrumentality of laws and systems, devised by the
politicians whom he execrates and denounces, and devised, moreover, often
enough, especially to keep out him and his. It is difficult to imagine
that a strong Government can be composed of materials so inharmonious.
Meanwhile, to the popular imagination, ‘the Emperor’ is the past; the
House of Bourbon is as historical as the House of Valois; a peasant is
little oftener reminded of the ‘third dynasty’ than of the long-haired
kings.
In discussing any Constitution, there are two ideas to be first got rid
of. The first is the idea of our barbarous ancestors—now happily banished
from all civilised society, but still prevailing in old manor-houses, in
rural parsonages, and other curious repositories of mouldering ignorance,
and which in such arid solitudes is thus expressed: ‘Why can’t they have
Kings, Lords and Commons, _like we have_? What fools foreigners are.’
The second pernicious mistake is, like the former, seldom now held upon
system, but so many hold it in bits and fragments, and without system,
that it is still rather formidable. I allude to the old idea which
still here creeps out in conversation, and sometimes in writing,—that
politics are simply a subdivision of immutable ethics; that there are
certain rights of men in all places and all times, which are the sole and
sufficient foundation of all government, and that accordingly a single
stereotype Government is to make the tour of the world—that you have
no more right to deprive a Dyak of his vote in a ‘possible’ Polynesian
Parliament, than you have to steal his mat.
Burke first taught the world at large, in opposition to both, and
especially to the latter of these notions, that politics are made of
time and place—that institutions are shifting things, to be tried by
and adjusted to the shifting conditions of a mutable world—that, in
fact, politics are but a piece of business—to be determined in every
case by the exact exigencies of that case; in plain English—by sense and
circumstances.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account