single respect it exactly resembles it. This kind may be called the
_self-delineative_, for in it the poet deals not with a particular
desire, sentiment, or inclination in his own mind, not with a special
phase of his own character, not with his love of war, his love of ladies,
his melancholy, but with his mind viewed as a whole, with the entire
essence of his own character. The first requisite of this poetry is
truth. It is in Plato’s phrase the soul ‘itself by itself’ aspiring to
view and take account of the particular notes and marks that distinguish
it from all other souls. The sense of reality is necessary to excellence;
the poet being himself, speaks like one who has authority; he knows and
must not deceive. This species of poetry, of course, adjoins on the
lyrical, out of which it historically arises. Such a poem as the ‘Elegy’
is, as it were, on the borders of the two; for while it expresses but
a single emotion, meditative, melancholy, you seem to feel that this
sentiment is not only then and for a moment the uppermost, but (as with
Gray it was) the habitual mood, the pervading emotion of his whole life.
Moreover, in one especial peculiarity, this sort of poetry is analogous
to the narrative or epic. Nothing certainly can, in a general aspect,
be more distantly removed one from another, the one dealing in external
objects and stirring events, the other with the stillness and repose of
the poet’s mind; but still in a single characteristic the two coincide.
They describe character as the painters say _in mass_. The defect of the
drama is, that it can delineate only motion. If a thoughtful person will
compare the character of Achilles, as we find it in Homer, with the more
surpassing creations of dramatic invention, say with Lear or Othello,
he will perhaps feel that character in repose, character on the lonely
beach, character in marble, character in itself, is more clearly and
perfectly seen in the epic narrative, than in the conversational drama.
It of course requires immense skill to make mere talk exhibit a man as
he is ἑτάρων ἄφαρ. Now this quality of epic poetry the self-delineative
precisely shares with it. It describes a character—the poet’s—alone by
itself. And therefore, when the great master in both kinds did not
hesitate to turn aside from his ‘high argument’ to say—
‘More safe I sing with mortal voice unchanged
To hoarse or mute, though fallen on evil days,’
pedants may prose as they please about the ‘impropriety’ of
‘interspersing’ species of composition which are by nature remote; but
Milton felt more profoundly that in its treatment of character the
egotistical poetry is allied to the epic; that he was putting together
elements which would harmoniously combine; that he was but exerting the
same faculties in either case—being guided thereto by a sure instinct,
the desire of genius to handle and combine every one of the subjects on
which it is genius.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account