In the execution of minor verses, we think we could show that Hartley
should have the praise of surpassing his father; but nevertheless it
would be absurd, on a general view, to compare the two men. Samuel
Taylor was so much bigger; what there was in his son was equally good,
perhaps, but then there was not much of it; outwardly and inwardly he was
essentially little. In poetry, for example, the father has produced two
longish poems, which have worked themselves right down to the extreme
depths of the popular memory, and stay there very firmly, in part from
their strangeness, but in part from their power. Of Hartley, nothing
of this kind is to be found—he could not write connectedly; he wanted
steadiness of purpose, or efficiency of will, to write so voluntarily;
and his genius did not, involuntarily, and out of its unseen workings,
present him with continuous creations; on the contrary, his mind teemed
with little fancies, and a new one came before the first had attained any
enormous magnitude. As his brother observed, he wanted ‘back thought.’
‘On what plan, Mr. Coleridge, are you arranging your books?’ inquired
a lady. ‘Plan, madam? I have no plan: at first I had a principle; but
then I had another, and now I do not know.’ The same contrast between
the ‘shaping mind’ of the father, and the gentle and minute genius of
the son, is said to have been very plain in their conversation. That of
Samuel was continuous, diffused, comprehensive.
‘Strongly it bears us along in swelling and limitless motion,
Nothing before and nothing behind, but the sky and the ocean.’
‘Great talker, certainly,’ said Hazlitt, ‘_if_ you will let him start
from no _data_, and come to no conclusion.’ The talk of Hartley, on the
contrary, though continuous in time, was detached in meaning; stating
hints and observations on particular subjects; glancing lightly from side
to side, but throwing no intense light on any, and exhausting none. It
flowed gently over small doubts and pleasant difficulties, rippling for a
minute sometimes into bombast, but lightly recovering and falling quietly
in ‘melody back.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account