American essays; Literature -- History and criticism
Young men and young women actually go to college to take a course in
Shakespeare or Chaucer or Dante or the Arthurian legends. The course
becomes a mere knowledge course, as Professor Corson suggests. My own
first acquaintance with Milton was through an exercise in grammar.
We parsed “Paradise Lost.” Much of the current college study of
Shakespeare is little better than parsing him. The minds of the pupils
are focused upon every word and line of the text, as the microscope
is focused upon a fly’s foot in the laboratory. The class probably
dissects a frog or a star-fish one day, and a great poet the next, and
it does both in about the same spirit. It falls upon one of these great
plays like hens upon a bone in winter: no meaning of word or phrase
escapes it, every line is literally picked to pieces; but of the poet
himself, of that which makes him what he is, his tremendous dramatic
power, how much do the students get? Very little, I fear. They have had
an intellectual exercise and not an emotional experience. They have
added to their knowledge, but have not taken a step in culture. To dig
into the roots and origins of the great poets is like digging into the
roots of an oak or a maple, the better to increase your appreciation of
the beauty of the tree. There stands the tree in all its summer glory;
will you really know it any better after you have laid bare every root
and rootlet? There stand Chaucer, Shakespeare, Dante, Homer. Read
them, give yourself to them, and master them if you are man enough.
The poets are not to be analyzed, they are to be enjoyed; they are not
to be studied, but to be loved; they are not for knowledge, but for
culture--to enhance our appreciation of life and our mastery over its
elements. All the mere facts about a poet’s work are as chaff compared
with the appreciation of one fine line or fine sentence. Why _study_
a great poet at all after the manner of the dissecting-room? Why not
rather seek to make the acquaintance of his living soul and to feel its
power?
The mere study of words, too,--of their origin and history, or of the
relation of your own language to some other,--how little that avails!
As little as a knowledge of the making and tempering of a sword would
help a man to be a good swordsman. What avails in literature is a quick
and delicate sense of the life and individuality of words--“a sense
practiced as a blind man’s touch,” or as a musician’s ear, so that the
magic of the true style is at once felt and appreciated; this, and
an equally quick and delicate sense of the life and individuality of
things. “Is there any taste in the white of an egg?” No more is there
in much merely correct writing. There is the use of language as the
vehicle of knowledge, and there is the use of it as an instrument of
the imagination. In Wordsworth’s line,
“The last to parley with the setting sun,”
in Whitman’s sentence,
“Oh, waves, I have fingered every shore with you,”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account