American essays; Literature -- History and criticism
What noble eloquence in Tacitus! Indeed, eloquence was natural to the
martial and world-subduing Roman; but his poetry is for the most part
of a secondary order. It is often said of French poetry that it is more
eloquent than poetic. Of English poetry the reverse is probably true,
though of such a poet as Byron it seems to me that eloquence is the
chief characteristic.
Byron never, to my notion, touches the deeper and finer poetic chords.
He is witty, he is brilliant, he is eloquent, but is he ever truly
poetical? He stirs the blood, he kindles the fancy, but does he ever
diffuse through the soul the joy and the light of pure poetry? Goethe
expressed almost unbounded admiration for Byron, yet admitted that he
was too worldly-minded, and that a great deal of his poetry should have
been fired off in Parliament in the shape of parliamentary speeches.
Wordsworth, on the other hand, when he was not prosy and heavy, was
poetical; he was never eloquent.
A fine sample of eloquence in poetry is Browning’s “How they brought
the Good News from Ghent to Aix.” Of its kind there is nothing in
the language to compare with it. One needs to read such a piece
occasionally as a moral sanitary measure; it aerates his emotions as
a cataract does a creek. Scott’s highest excellence as a poet is his
eloquence. The same is true of Macaulay and of Campbell, though the
latter’s “To the Rainbow” breathes the spirit of true poetry.
Among our own poets Halleck’s “Marco Bozzaris” thrills us with its
fiery eloquence. Dr. Holmes’s “Old Ironsides” also is just what such
a poem should be, just what the occasion called for, a rare piece of
rhymed eloquence.
Eloquence is so good, so refreshing, it is such a noble and elevating
excitement, that one would fain have more of it, even in poetry. It is
too rare and precious a product to be valued lightly.
Here is a brief example of Byron’s eloquence:--
“There, where death’s brief pang was quickest.
And the battle’s wreck lay thickest,
Strewed beneath the advancing banner
Of the eagles’ burning crest,--
There with thunder-clouds to fan her
Victory beaming from her breast!
While the broken line enlarging
Fell, or fled along the plain;--
There be sure _Murat_ was charging!
There he ne’er shall charge again!”
This from Tennyson is of another order:--
“Thy voice is heard through rolling drums
That beat to battle where he stands;
Thy face across his fancy comes,
And gives the battle to his hands:
A moment, while the trumpets blow,
He sees his brood about thy knee;
The next, like fire, he meets the foe,
And strikes him dead for thine and thee.”
The chief value of all patriotic songs and poems, like Mrs. Howe’s
“Battle Hymn of the Republic,” or Mr. Stedman’s John Brown poem, or
Randall’s “Maryland,” or Burns’s “Bannnockburn,” or Whitman’s “Beat!
Beat! Drums,” is their impassioned eloquence. Patriotism, war, wrong,
slavery, these are the inspirers of eloquence.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account