Little rays of moonshineHerbert, A. P. (Alan Patrick)
General
Little rays of moonshine
Herbert, A. P. (Alan Patrick)
English essays -- 20th century; English wit and humor
The correct answer would have been, of course, “Well, as a matter
of fact I do”; but you cannot make answers of that kind to Editors;
they don’t understand it. And that brings you to the real drawback of
comic poetry; it means constant truck with Editors. But I must not be
drawn into a discussion about them. In a special lecture--two special
lectures---- Quite.
The lowest form of comic poetry is, of course, the Limerick; but it is
a mistake to suppose that it is the easiest. It is more difficult to
finish a Limerick than to finish anything in the world. You see, in a
Limerick you cannot begin:--
There was an old man of West _Ham_
and go on
Who formed an original _plan_.
finishing the last line with _limb_ or _hen_ or _bun_. A serious writer
could do that with impunity, and indeed with praise, but the more
exacting traditions of Limerical composition insist that, having fixed
on _Ham_ as the end of the first line, you must find two other rhymes
to _Ham_, and good rhymes too. This is why there is so large a body of
uncompleted Limericks. For many years I have been trying to finish the
following unfinished masterpiece:--
There was a young man who said “_Hell!_
I don’t think I feel very well----”
That was composed on the Gallipoli Peninsula; in fact it was composed
under fire; indeed I remember now that we were going over the top at
the time. But in the quiet days of Peace I can get no further with it.
It only shows how much easier it is to begin a Limerick than to end it.
Apart from the subtle phrasing of the second line this poem is
noteworthy because it is cast in the classic form. All the best
Limericks are about a young man, or else an old one, who said some
short sharp monosyllable in the first line. For example:--
There was a young man who said “_If_----
Now what are the rhymes to _if_? Looking up my _Rhyming Dictionary_ I
see they are:--
cliff hieroglyph hippogriff
skiff sniff stiff tiff whiff
Of these one may reject _hippogriff_ at once, as it is in the wrong
metre. _Hieroglyph_ is attractive, and we might do worse than:--
There was a young man who said “If
One murdered a hieroglyph----”
Having, however, no very clear idea of the nature of a hieroglyph
I am afraid that this will also join the long list of unfinished
masterpieces. Personally I should incline to something of this kind:--
There was a young man who said “If
I threw myself over a cliff
I do not believe
_One_ person would grieve----”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account