Living Fountains or Broken Cisterns: An Educational Problem for ProtestantsSutherland, E. A. (Edward Alexander)
Religion
Living Fountains or Broken Cisterns: An Educational Problem for Protestants
Sutherland, E. A. (Edward Alexander)
Church and education; Education -- History; Religious education
“One day Mary was bending over a tablet writing words on both sides of a
straight line, like multiplied numerators and denominators.
“‘What are you at now?’ asked grandma.
“Mary answered with pride, ‘I am diagraming.’
“‘In the name of sense, what’s diagraming?’
“‘It’s mental discipline. Miss Cram says I have a fine mind that needs
developing. Look here, grandma, now this is the correct placing of
elements. _Fourscore_ and _seven_ are joined by the word _and_, a
subordinate connective copulative conjunction. It modifies _years_, the
attribute of the preposition. _Ago_ is a modal verb of past time. The
root of the first clause is—.
“‘Why, that’s Lincoln’s speech at Gettysburg. I keep it in my work-basket
and know it by heart.’
“‘Indeed! Well, _ours_ is a simple personal—.’
“‘That’s enough. If President Lincoln had been brought up on such stuff,
that speech would never have been written. He called a noun a noun, and
was done with it.’”[173]
Montaigne could scarcely have given a more vivid description had he seen
the grind of modern education, where grades are strictly kept, and all
children, the strong and the tender alike, are forced through the same
process. There is no relief save in dropping by the wayside when disease
fastens its tendrils on the human frame.
Against this system all educational reformers have striven, but it
remains with us still. Christian parents, could they see the relative
value of soul and mental culture, would demand the establishment of a new
order of things. Christian education alone can effect a cure.
[Sidenote: Nature-study to prevent cramming]
Comenius strove to correct this error by the introduction of
nature-study. He says: “The right instruction of youth does not consist
in cramming them with a mass of words, phrases, sentences, and opinions
collected from authors, but in unfolding the understanding, that many
little streams may flow therefrom as from a living fountain.... Why shall
we not, instead of dead books, open the living book of nature? Not the
shadows of things, but the things themselves, which make an impression on
the senses and the imagination, are to be brought before youth. By actual
observation, not by a verbal description of things, must instruction
begin.... Men must be led as far as possible to draw their wisdom, not
from books, but from a consideration of heaven and earth, oaks and
beeches; that is, they must know and examine things themselves, and not
simply be contented with the observations and testimony of others.”
His fundamental principles were, “Education is a development of the whole
man,” and “Many studies are to be avoided as dissipating the mental
strength.”
[Sidenote: Modern science study and doubt]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account