Looking Further Forward: An Answer to Looking Backward by Edward Bellamy — John Shaqi
Looking Further Forward: An Answer to Looking Backward by Edward BellamyMichaelis, Richard
Science
Looking Further Forward: An Answer to Looking Backward by Edward Bellamy
Michaelis, Richard
Bellamy, Edward, 1850-1898. Looking backward; Utopian fiction; Utopias -- Fiction; Utopias in literature
“Yes. Dr. Leete is the most influential leader of the administration
party in Boston. I owe it to his kind interference, that I am still
connected with the college.”
Noticing that I did not know how to construe this statement, Mr. Forest
added:
“When, in comparing the civilization of your days with ours, I came
to the conclusion, that communism had proved a failure, I was accused
of misleading and corrupting the students and the usual sentence in
such cases: “confinement in an insane asylum”, was passed. Because,
it is claimed, that only a madman could find fault with the best
organization of society ever introduced. Dr. Leete, however, declared,
that my insanity was so harmless, that confinement in an asylum seemed
unnecessary, besides being too expensive. I could still earn my living
by doing light work about the college building; and my case would serve
as a warning to all the professors and students to be careful in
their expressions and teachings. So I retained the liberty in which we
glory and was spared doing street cleaning or some such work, which is
generally awarded to “kickers” against the administration.”
“The students seem to share your opinion, at least they received my
remarks very coldly,” I remarked, in order to avoid a discussion of the
qualities of my host.
Mr. Forest’s keen grey eyes rested for a moment upon my face, and then
he said in a friendly tone:
“I believe you were convinced of what you said, Mr. West; but did it
not occur to you, that you treated your time and your contemporaries
very severely? Did competition really demand, that one should defraud
his neighbor, grind his laborers, sweat his debtors and snatch the
bread from others? Were the majority of the men of your time swindlers
and Shylocks? Were the laborers all slaves, working each day until
completely exhausted? I remember distinctly, that the wage-workers of
your time struck frequently for eight hours, declining to work nine
or ten hours per diem for good pay. I think you had a strong, proud
and independent class of laborers, who could not fairly be regarded
as slaves. And as for the girls, I have seen the statements and
complaints, that help for housekeeping was very scarce in your days and
was paid from $2. to $5. per week, with board, so that there was no
excuse for any decent girl to sell herself for bread.--Of course your
state of civilization was very far from being faultless; in fact there
is no such thing as perfection in anything. But your description of the
civilization of the nineteenth century is painted in such dark colors,
that our students, who are somewhat familiar with the history of those
days, could not very well enthuse over your lecture; especially as many
of these young men do not regard our present institutions with such
complete admiration as you do. I speak frankly, Mr. West, and I hope
you will excuse my frankness, because of my desire to serve you in
describing men, things and institutions as I see them.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account