Religious services generally, he says in 1515-16 to the young monks,
with a boldness which he takes little pains to conceal, “are in fact
to-day more a hindrance than a help” to true piety. Speaking of the
manner of their performance he says with manifest exaggeration, that
it is such as to be no longer prayer. “We only insult God more when we
recite them.... We acquire a false security of conscience as though
we had really prayed, and that is a terrible danger!”[720] Then he
goes on to explain “Almost all follow their calling at the present
day with distaste and without love, and those who are zealous place
their trust in it and merely crucify their conscience.” He speaks
of the “superstitious exercises of piety” which are performed from
gross ignorance, and sets up as the ideal, that each one should be at
liberty to decide what he will undertake in the way of priestly or
monastic observances, among which he enumerates expressly “celibacy,
the tonsure, the habit and the recitation of the Breviary.”[721]
We see from this that he was not much attached even to the actual
obligations of his profession, and we may fairly surmise that such
a disposition had not come upon him suddenly; these were rather the
moral accompaniments of the change in his theological views and
really date from an earlier period. We can also recognise in them the
practical results of his strong opposition to the Observantines of the
Order, which grew into an antagonism to all zeal in the religious
life and in the service of God, and even to the observance of the
duties, great or small, of one’s state of life.
With his mystical idealism he demands, on the other hand, what is
contrary to reason and impossible of attainment. Prayer, according
to him, if rightly performed, is the “most strenuous work and calls
for the greatest energy”; “the spirit must be raised to God by the
employment of constant violence”; this must be done “with fear
and trembling,” because the biblical precept says: “work out your
salvation with fear and trembling”; in short, it is, he declares,
“the most difficult and most tedious affair” (“_difficillima et
tædiosissima_”).[722] Only then is it not so “when the Spirit of God
takes us beneath His wings and carries us, or when misfortune forces
us to pray from our hearts.”
He can describe graphically the lukewarmness and distractions which
accompany the recitation of the Divine Office, and can do so from
experience if we may trust what he says in 1535 of himself: “I have in
my day spent much time in the recitation of the canonical Hours, and
often the Psalm or Hour was ended before I knew whether I was at the
beginning or in the middle of it.”[723]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account