It is true that after such strong outbursts as the above, Luther would
often moderate his language. Thus he says, shortly after the utterance
just quoted: “I do not wish to disparage virginity nor to tempt people
away from it to the conjugal state. Let each one do as he is able and
as he feels God has ordained for him.... The state of chastity is
probably better on earth as having less of trouble and care, and not
for its own sake only, but in order to allow one to preach and wait
upon the Word of God, as St. Paul says 1 Corinthians vii. 34.”[298]
But then he continues, following up the idea which possesses him: “He
who desires to live single undertakes an impossible struggle”; such
people become “full of harlotry and all impurity of the flesh, and at
last drown themselves therein and fall into despair; therefore such a
vow is invalid, being contrary to the Word and work of God.”[299] Most
of the younger religious, he declares elsewhere in a description which
is as repulsive as it is untrue, were unable to control themselves,
for it is not possible to take from fire its power of burning; among
them, and the clergy, there prevailed “either harlotry under the name
of a spiritual and chaste life, or an impure, unwilling, wretched,
forlorn chastity, so that the wretchedness is greater than anyone
could believe or tell.”[300]
What Luther says would leave us under the impression--to put the
most charitable interpretation upon his words--that he had lived in
sad surroundings; yet what we know of the Augustinian monasteries at
Erfurt and Wittenberg affords as little ground for such an assumption
as the conditions prevailing in the other friaries, whether Franciscan
or Dominican, with which he was acquainted. He speaks again and again
as though he knew nothing of the satisfaction with their profession
which filled whole multitudes who were faithful to their vows, and
which was the result of serious discipline and a devout mind. He goes
on: “They extol chastity loudly, but live in the midst of impurity....
These pious foundations and convents, where the faith [according
to his teaching] is not practised stoutly and heartily,”[301] must
surely be gates of hell. Those who refrain from marriage for the sake
of the Kingdom of Heaven are, he considers, “so rare, that among
a thousand men there is scarcely to be found one, for they are a
special miracle of God’s own.”[302] He who enters a monastery, he
writes (not in the least afraid of speaking as though this had been
his own experience), can, in reality, never avoid sinning against his
vow. The Pope leaves such a one to be, as it were, burnt and roasted
in the fire; he accordingly might well be compared to the sacrifice
which the children of Israel offered to Moloch the fiery idol. “What a
Sodom and Gomorrha,” he cries in another passage, “has the devil set
up by such laws and vows, making of that rare gift chastity a thing
of utter wretchedness.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account