Shall we not do good works? Shall we not pray any more, fast, found
monasteries, become monks or nuns, or do similar works? The answer
is: “There are two kinds of good works, some which are looked upon as
good,” i.e. “our own self-chosen works,” such as “special fasting,
special prayers, wearing a special dress or joining an Order.” “None
of this is ordained by God,” and “Christian faith looks to nothing
save Christ only,” therefore these works we must leave severely alone.
There are, on the other hand, works which are better than these.
“When once we have laid hold upon Christ, then good Christian works
follow, such as God has commanded and which man performs not for
his own advantage but in the service of his neighbour.” But even of
these works Luther is careful to add that they should be performed
“without placing any trust in them for justification.” “Fasting is
a good work,” but then, “the devil himself does not eat too much,”
and sometimes even “a Jew” fasts; “prayer is also a good work,” but
it does not consist in “much mumbling or shouting,” and even “the
Turk prays much with his lips.” “No one may or can bear the name of
Christian except by the work of Christ.”[1031]
Thus, even where he is forced to admit good works, he must needs add a
warning.
Finally, where he is exhorting to the patient bearing of crosses, he
immediately, and most strangely, restricts this exercise of virtue
to the limits of his own experience: One bears the cross when he is
unjustly proclaimed “a heretic and evil-doer,” not “when he is sick in
bed”; to bear the cross is to be “deprived of interior consolation,”
and to be severely tried by “God’s hand and by His anger.”[1032]
In the new congregation at Erfurt it was a question of the very
foundations of the moral life. Yet in Luther’s addresses we miss the
necessary exhortations to a change of heart, to struggle against the
passions and overcome sensuality. Neither is the sinner exhorted to
repentance, penance, contrition, fear of God and a firm purpose of
amendment, nor are the more zealous encouraged to the active exercise
of the love of God, to self-denial according to the virtues of their
state, or to sanctification by the use of those means which Luther
still continued to recognise, at least to a certain extent, such
as the Eucharist. All his exhortations merge into this one thing,
trust in Christ. He preached, indeed, one part of the sermon of the
Precursor, viz. “The Kingdom of God is at hand”; with the other:
“Bring forth therefore fruit worthy of penance,” he would have nothing
to do.
As far as the change at Erfurt went, the moral condition of the town
was to serve more than ever as a refutation of Luther’s expectation
that “the works will follow.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account