Melanchthon and Luther diverged in their use of this picture from
the older and more harmless interpretation, i.e. that which saw in
it a reference to earthly trials, or a judgment on the politics
of the Pope. They, on the contrary, regarded it as a denunciation
by heaven of the Papacy itself and of the Roman Church with all
its “abominations.” Quite possibly the transition had been quietly
effected by the Bohemian Brethren. Luther, however, says Lange,
“was the first to make it public property.” “The Pope-Ass is for
this reason the most interesting example of the whole teratological
literature, because in it we can see the transition visibly effected.”
The same author detects in the joint work of the two Wittenbergers “a
polemical tone hitherto unheard of”; of Melanchthon’s Pope-Ass, he
says: “It is probably the most unworthy work we have of Melanchthon’s.
He himself naturally believed implicitly in what he wrote.... That
Melanchthon acquitted himself of his task with particular skill cannot
be affirmed.”[430]
Just as the Monk-Calf had been applied to Luther himself previous
to his own polemical interpretation of it, so, after the appearance
of his and Melanchthon’s joint publication, both the Calf and the
Ass were repeatedly taken by the Catholic controversialists to
represent Luther and his innovations. The sixteenth century, as
already hinted, loved to dwell upon and expound such freaks of nature.
Authors of repute had done so before Luther, at least to the extent
of making such the subject of indifferent compositions, as the poet
J. Franciscus Vitalis of Palermo had done (“_De monstro nato_”) in
the case of a monstrosity said to have been born at Ravenna in 1511
or 1512; the Humanist Jacob Locher, at the turn of the fifteenth
and sixteenth centuries, dealt with a similar case in his “_Carmen
heroicum_.” Conrad Lycosthenes published at Basle, in 1557, a
compendium of the prodigies of nature (“_Prodigiorum ac ostentorum
chronicon_”), in which he instances a large number of such freaks
famous even before Luther’s day. Of the earlier Humanists Sebastian
Brant composed some Elegies on the Marvels of Nature. The Wittenberg
work on the Calf and Ass must be put in its proper setting, and
judged according to the standard of its age; although, owing to its
religious bias, it far exceeds in extravagance anything that had
appeared so far, it nevertheless was an outgrowth of its time.
3. Proofs of the Divine Mission. Miracles and Prophecies
How was Luther to give actual proof of the reality of his call and of
his mission to introduce such far-reaching ecclesiastical innovations?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account