Leo Judæ, one of the leaders of the Swiss Reformation, and an opponent
of Wittenberg, “accuses Luther of drunkenness and all manner of
things; such a bishop [he says] he would not permit to rule over even
the most insignificant see.” Thus in a letter to Bucer on April 24,
1534, quoted by Theodore Kolde in his “Analecta Lutherana,”[919] who,
unfortunately, does not give the actual text. According to Kolde,
Leo Judæ continues: “Even the devil confesses Christ. I believe that
since the time of the Apostles no one has ever spoken so disgracefully
(‘_turpiter_’) as Luther, so ridiculously and irreligiously. Unless
we resist him betimes, what else can we expect of the man but that he
will become another Pope, who orders things first one way then another
(‘_fingit et refingit_’), consigns this one to Satan and that one to
heaven, puts one man out of the Church and receives another into it
again, until things come to such a pass that he acts as Judge over all
whilst no one pays the least attention to him?” With the exception of
rejecting infant baptism, so Kolde goes on, Luther appeared to Judæ
no better than Schwenckfeld, with whom Bucer would have nought to
do; Judæ proceeds: “Not for one hundred thousand crowns would I have
all evangelical preachers to resemble Luther; no one could compare
with him for his wealth of abuse and for his woman-like, impotent
agitation; his clamour and readiness of tongue are nowhere to be
equalled.”[920]
Powerful indeed is the rhetorical outburst of Zwingli in a letter to
Conrad Sam the preacher of Ulm, dated August 30, 1528: “May I be lost
if he [Luther] does not surpass Faber in foolishness, Eck in impurity,
Cochlæus in impudence, and to sum it up shortly, all the vicious in
vice.”[921]
Heinrich Bullinger, Zwingli’s successor, attacks Luther in his
“Warhafften Bekanntnuss” of 1545 in reply to the latter’s “Kurtz
Bekentnis”: “The booklet [Luther’s] is so crammed with devils,
unchristian abuse, immoral, wicked, and unclean words, anger, rage and
fury that all who read it without being as mad as the author must be
greatly surprised and astonished, that so old, gifted, experienced
and reputable a man cannot keep within bounds but must break out
into such rudeness and filth as to ruin his cause in the eyes of all
right-thinking men.”[922]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account