In the “Internationale Wochenschrift” Heinrich Finke pointed out that
he had examined hundreds of Late-mediæval sermons on the position of
women, with the result, that “it is impossible to discover in them any
contempt for woman.”[439] The fact is, that “there exist countless
statements of the sanctity of marriage and its sacramental character
... statements drawn from theologians of the highest standing,
Fathers, Saints and Doctors of the Church. Indeed, towards the close
of the Middle Ages, they grow still more numerous. The most popular of
the monks, whether Franciscans or Dominicans, have left us matrimonial
handbooks which imply the existence of that simple, happy family
life they depict and encourage.”[440] Finke recalls the 15th-century
theologian, Raymond of Sabunde, who points out how union with God
in love may be reproduced in marriage. Countless theologians are at
one with him here, and follow Scripture in representing the union
of Christ with the Church as an exalted figure of the marriage-bond
between man and wife (Eph. v. 25, 32). Of the respect which the
ancient Church exhibited towards women Finke declares: “Never has
the praise of women been sung more loudly than in the sermons of the
Fathers and in the theological tractates of the Schoolmen.” Here “one
picture follows another, each more dazzling than the last.”[441]
Certainly we must admit, as he does, that it is for the most part the
ideal of virginity which inspires them, and that it is the good,
chaste, virtuous wife and widow whom they extol, rather than woman
_qua_ woman, as a noble part of God’s creation. Their vocation as
spiritual teachers naturally explains this; and if, for the same
cause, they seem to be very severe in their strictures on feminine
faults, or to strike harsh notes in their warnings on the spiritual
dangers of too free intercourse with the female sex, this must not
be looked upon as “hatred of women,” as has been done erroneously on
the strength of some such passages in the case of St. Antoninus of
Florence and Cardinal Dominici.[442]
“Just as Church and Councils energetically took the side of marriage”
when it was decried in certain circles,[443] so the accusation of
recent times that, in the Middle Ages, woman was universally looked
upon with contempt, cannot stand; according to Finke this was not the
case, even in “ascetical circles,” and “still less elsewhere.”[444]
The author adduces facts which “utterly disprove any such general
disdain for woman.”[445]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account