“From this,” they continue, “no great gossip or scandal will result,
for it is not unusual for Princes to keep ‘_concubinas_,’ and, though
not everyone is aware of the circumstances, yet reasonable people will
bear this in mind and be better pleased with such a manner of life
than with adultery or dissolute and immoral living.”
Yet, once again, they point out that, were the bigamy to become
a matter of public knowledge, the opinion would gain ground that
polygamy was perfectly lawful to all, and that everyone might follow
the precedent; the result would also be that the enemies of the
Evangel would cry out that the Evangelicals were not one whit better
than the Anabaptists, who were likewise polygamists and, in fact, just
the same as the Turks. Further, the great Lords would be the first
to give the example to private persons to do likewise. As it was,
the Hessian aristocracy was bad enough, and many of its members were
strongly opposed to the Evangel on earthly grounds; these would become
still more hostile were the bigamy to become publicly known. Lastly,
the Prince must bear in mind the injury to his “good name” which the
tidings of his act would cause amongst foreign potentates.
A paragraph appended to the memorandum is, according to recent
investigation, from Luther’s own pen and, at any rate, is quite in
his style.[60] It refers to Philip’s threat to seek the Emperor’s
intervention, a step which would not have been at all to the taste
of the Wittenbergers, for it was obvious that this would cripple
Philip’s action as Protector of the Evangelicals. This menace had
plainly excited and troubled Luther. He declares in the concluding
sentences, that the Emperor before whom the Prince threatened to lay
the case, was a man who looked upon adultery as a small sin; there was
great reason to fear that he shared the faith of the Pope, Cardinals,
Italians, Spaniards and Saracens; he would pay no heed to the Prince’s
request but only use him as a cat’s-paw. They had found him out to be
a false and faithless man, who had forgotten the true German spirit.
The Emperor, as the Landgrave might see for himself, did not trouble
himself about any Christian concerns, left the Turks unopposed and was
only interested in fomenting plots in Germany for the increase of the
Burgundian power. Hence it was to be hoped that pious German Princes
would have nothing to do with his faithless practices.
Such are the contents of Luther and Melanchthon’s written reply. Bucer,
glad of the success achieved, at once proceeded with the memorandum to
the Electoral Court.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account