His half-heartedness and love of compromise were a cause of many
hardships to him, particularly at the time of the so-called Interims
of Augsburg and Leipzig. It was a question of introducing the Augsburg
Interim into the Saxon Electorate after the latter, owing to the War
of Schmalkalden, had come under the rule of the new Elector Maurice.
Melanchthon had at first opposed the provisions of this Interim, by
means of which the Emperor hoped gradually to bring the Protestants
back to the fold. In Dec., 1548, however, he, together with other
theologians, formally accepted the Leipzig articles, which, owing
to their similarity with the Augsburg Interim, were dubbed by his
opponents the “Leipzig Interim,”[988] In this the “moot observances
(Adiaphora), i.e. those which may be kept without any contravention
of Divine Scripture,” were extended by Melanchthon so as to include
the reintroduction of fasting, festivals, not excluding even Corpus
Christi, images of the Saints in the churches, the Latin liturgy, the
Canonical Hours in Latin and even a sort of hierarchy. Melanchthon
also agreed to the demand for the recognition of the seven sacraments.
By strongly emphasising his own doctrine of synergism, he brought the
Wittenberg teaching on Justification much nearer to Catholic dogma; he
even dealt a death-blow to the genuine doctrine of Luther by appending
his signature to the following proposition: “God does not deal with
man as with a block of wood, but so draws him that his will also
co-operates.” In addition to this the true character of Luther’s _sola
fides_, or assurance of salvation, was veiled by Melanchthon under the
formula: “True faith accepts, together with other articles, that of
the ‘Forgiveness of Sins.’”
Hence when Flacius Illyricus, Amsdorf, Gallus, Wigand, Westphal and
others loudly protested against Melanchthon as though he had denied
Luther’s doctrine, they were not so very far wrong. The result of
their vigorous opposition and of the number of those who sided with
them was that Melanchthon gradually ceased to be the head of the
Lutheran Church, becoming merely the leader of a certain party.
Later on, in 1552, when the position of public affairs in Germany was
more favourable to Protestantism, Melanchthon admitted that he had
been wrong in his views concerning the Adiaphora, since, after all,
they were not so unimportant as he had at first thought. In order to
pacify his opponents he included the following proposition in his form
of examination for new preachers: “We ought to profess, not the Papal
errors, Interim, etc. ... but to remain faithful to the pure Divine
teaching of the Gospel.”[989]
Opposition to the “Papal errors” was indeed the one thing to which he
steadfastly adhered; this negative side of his attitude never varied,
whatever changes may have taken place in his positive doctrines.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account