Of Carlstadt Luther once said, referring to the rivalry between
the pair: “He persuaded himself that there was no more learned man
on earth than he; what I write that he imitates and seeks to copy
me.” After a profession of personal humility, Luther concludes: “And
yet, by God’s Grace, I am more learned than all the Sophists and
theologians of the Schools.”[1029]
Though Luther never grows weary of insisting against the heretics at
home on the “public, common doctrine,” and of instancing the fell
consequences of pride and obstinacy, even going so far as to predict that
they will in all likelihood never be converted because founders of sects
rarely retrace their steps and recant,[1030] yet he never seems to have
perceived that the point of all this might equally well have been turned
against himself.
The blindness of such heretics he describes in a tract of 1526 dedicated
to Queen Mary of Hungary:
“Here we may all of us well be afraid, and particularly all heretics
and false teachers.… Such a temper [obstinacy in sticking to one’s
own opinion] penetrates like water into the inmost recesses and like
oil into the very bone, and becomes our daily clothing. Then it comes
about that one party curses the other, and the doctrine of one is rank
poison and malediction to the other, and his own doctrine nothing
but blessing and salvation; this we now see among our fanatics and
Papists. Then everything is lost. The masses are not converted; a few,
whom God has chosen, come right again, but the others remain under
the curse and even regard it as a precious thing.… Nor have I ever
read of heresiarchs being converted; they remain obdurate in their
own conceit, the oil has gone into the bone … and has become part of
their nature. They allow none to find fault with them and brook no
opposition. This is the sin against the Holy Ghost for which there is
no forgiveness.”[1031]
In the same writing he describes the heretics’ way of speaking: “The
heretics give themselves up to idle talk so that one hears of nothing
but their dreams.… They overflow with words; all evildoers tend to
become garrulous. As a boiling pot foams and bubbles over, so they too
overflow with the talk of which their heart is full.… They stand stiff
upon their doctrine about which there is no lack of ranting.”[1032]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account