The description (which seats so well on Luther himself) proceeds:
“Those are heretics and apostates who follow their own ideas rather
than the common tradition of Christendom, who transgress the teaching
of their fathers and separate themselves from the common ways and
usages of the whole of Christendom, who, out of pure wantonness,
invent new ways and methods without cause, and contrary to Holy
Writ.”[1033]—“They misread the Word of God according to their whim and
make it mean what they please. In short they undertake something out
of the common and invent a belief of their own, regardless of God’s
Word.… God must put up with their doctrine and life as being alone
holy and Godly.”[1034]
Again and again he brands pride as the cause of all heresy: “This
is the reason; they think much of themselves, which, indeed, is the
cause and well-spring of all heresies, for, as Augustine also says,
‘Ambition is the mother of all heresies.’ Thus Zwingli and Bucer
now put forward a new doctrine.… So dangerous a thing is pride in
the clergy.”[1035]—“We cannot sufficiently be on our guard against
this deadly vice. Vices of the body are gross, and we feel them to
be such, but this vice can always deck itself out with the glory of
God, as though it had God’s Word on its side. But beneath the outward
veil there is nothing but vain glory.”[1036]—“Lo, here you have in
brief the cause and ground of all idolatry, heresy, hypocrisy and
error, what the prophets inveigh against, and what was the cause of
their being put to death, and against which the whole of Scripture
witnesses. It all comes from obstinacy and conceit and the ideas of
natural reason which puffs itself up … and fancies it knows enough,
and can find its way for itself, etc.”[1037]
Such statements of Luther’s are of supreme importance for judging of his
Divine Mission. In his frame of mind it became at last an impossibility
for him to realise that his hostility and intolerance towards “heretics”
within his fold could redound on himself, or that he was contradicting
himself in continuing to proclaim freedom, or at least in continuing
to make the fullest use of it himself. In reality he was living in a
world of his own, and his mental state cannot be judged of by the usual
standards.
_“Heretics” who cannot be sure of their Cause_
Apart from the “pride of the heretics,” another idea of Luther’s deserves
attention, viz. that those teachers who differed from him, in their heart
of hearts, knew him to be in the right, or at least neither were nor
could be quite certain of their own doctrines. Of any call in their case
there could be no question; his call, however, was above doubt, seeing
his certainty. Hence, in his dealings with the “sectarians” we once
again find the same strange attitude, as he had exhibited towards the
“Papists,” who, according to him, likewise were withstanding their own
conscience and lacked any real call.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account