Lynch-law; an investigation into the history of lynching in the United StatesCutler, James Elbert
Philosophy
Lynch-law; an investigation into the history of lynching in the United States
Cutler, James Elbert
Lynching -- United States
It has been said by some that the first instance of the operation of
lynch-law in America was in December, 1763, at Paxtang (now Harrisburg),
Pennsylvania. Indian scalping parties had been laying waste the
settlements with relentless fury, and the appeals of the settlers to the
Quaker government for help had been treated with contempt. Exasperated
at the policy pursued by the Quakers toward the Indians, the
Scotch-Irish who had settled in Lancaster and Cumberland counties formed
several companies of Rangers to patrol the borders and give protection.
“About the middle of December, word was brought to the settlers living
at Paxtang, that an Indian known to have committed depredations in the
vicinity had been traced to Conestoga. Matthew Smith, a man of influence
and popularity among his associates, called together a number of the
Paxtang Rangers, and led them to the Conestoga settlement. One of the
men saw an Indian issuing from a house, and thought that he recognized
him as the savage who had killed his own mother. Firing his rifle, he
brought the Indian down. Then, with a loud shout, the furious mob rushed
into the cabins, and killed all the Indians whom they found there, some
six in number. Fourteen of the Conestogas managed to escape, and,
fleeing to Lancaster, were given a place of refuge in the county jail.
While there, word was again carried to the Paxtang men that an Indian,
known to have murdered the relatives of one of their number, was among
those who had received the protection of the Lancaster magistrates. This
again aroused a feeling of rage and resentment amongst the Rangers. On
December 27, some fifty of them, under the leadership of Lazarus
Stewart, marched to Lancaster, broke open the jail, and with the fury of
a mob massacred every Indian contained therein, man, woman, and
child.”[68]
In connection with this incident it has been suggested that the
Scotch-Irish are to blame for the introduction of lynch-law in America;
that they brought with them traditions of the administration of summary
justice in Mediæval Scotland, and, amidst the perils of the frontier,
quickly resorted to the ancient methods of suppressing violence and
depredation. The case of the Regulators in the Carolinas is also cited
as an instance of the Scotch-Irish backwoodsmen taking the
administration of justice into their own hands, when their rulers failed
to provide for them a safe government. It is said that this same
self-reliant spirit is exhibited in the “family feuds of Kentucky, which
for the most part seem peculiar to families bearing Scottish names.”[69]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account