Magna Carta: A Commentary on the Great Charter of King John: With an Historical IntroductionMcKechnie, William Sharp
History
Magna Carta: A Commentary on the Great Charter of King John: With an Historical Introduction
McKechnie, William Sharp
Constitutional history -- England -- Sources; Law -- England -- History; Law -- England -- Sources; Magna Carta
If it can be proved that John, almost from his accession, deliberately
altered all three of these well-established rules, and that too in the
teeth of the keen opposition of a high-spirited baronage whose members
felt that their pride and prestige as well as their money-bags were
attacked, a distinct step is taken towards understanding the crisis of
1215. Such knowledge would explain why a storm, long brewing, burst in
John’s reign, neither sooner nor later; and even why some of the
disreputable stories told by the chroniclers and accepted by Blackstone
and others, found inventors and willing believers.
It is here maintained that John did make changes in all three
directions; and, further, that the incidence of this increase in
feudal burdens was rendered even more unendurable by two
considerations:—because at his accession there remained unpaid
(particularly from the fiefs of the northern knights) large arrears of
the scutages imposed in his brother’s reign,[132] and because in June,
1212, John drew the feudal chain tight by a drastic and galling
measure. In that month he instituted a strict inquest into the amount
of feudal service exigible from every estate in England, to prevent
any dues escaping his wide net, and to revive all services and
payments that had lapsed or were in danger of lapsing.
-----
Footnote 132:
Miss Norgate, _John Lackland_, p. 122.
-----
That he made the first two changes becomes a certainty from a glance at
the table of scutages actually extorted during his reign, as these are
here copied from a list compiled by a writer of authority who has no
special theory to support,[133] viz.:
First scutage of reign— 1198-9— 2 marks per knight’s fee.
Second " " 1200-1 2 " "
Third " " 1201-2 2 " "
Fourth " " 1202-3 2 " "
Fifth " " 1203-4 2 " "
Sixth " " 1204-5 2 " "
Seventh " " 1205-6 20s. "
Eighth " " 1209-10 2 marks "
Ninth " " 1210-11 2 " "
Tenth " " 1210-11 20s. "
Eleventh " " 1213-14 3 marks "
-----
Footnote 133:
Miss Norgate, _John Lackland_, p. 123 note, correcting Swereford’s
lists in the _Red Book of Exchequer_.
-----
It will be seen that, in the very first year of his reign, John took a
scutage, and that, too, at a rate above the established normal, at two
marks per _scutum_ (only once equalled, thirty years before, and then
under special circumstances). Even one such exaction must have made the
already sulky Crown tenants look askance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account