Mahan on naval warfare : $b Selections from the writing of Rear Admiral Alfred T. MahanMahan, A. T. (Alfred Thayer)
History
Mahan on naval warfare : $b Selections from the writing of Rear Admiral Alfred T. Mahan
Mahan, A. T. (Alfred Thayer)
Naval art and science; Naval strategy; Sea-power
Administration being a term of very general application, it will be
expected that that of the navy should present close analogies, and even
points of identity, with other forms of administration; for instance,
that in it, as elsewhere, efficiency of result will be better secured by
individual responsibility than by collective responsibility. But, along
with general resemblance, naval administration is very clearly and
sharply differentiated by the presence of an element which is foreign to
almost all other activities of life in countries like Great Britain and
the United States. The military factor is to it not merely incidental,
but fundamental; whatever other result may be achieved, naval
administration has failed unless it provides to the nation an efficient
fighting body, directed by well-trained men, animated by a strong
military spirit. On the other hand, many of the operations connected
with it differ from those common to civil life only in a certain
particularity of method. This is true in principal measure of the
financial management, of the medical establishment, and to a
considerable though much smaller degree of the manufacturing processes
connected with the production of naval material. The business routine of
even the most military department of a naval administration is in itself
more akin to civil than to military life: but it by no means follows
that those departments would be better administered under men of civil
habits of thought than by those of military training. The method exists
for the result, and an efficient fighting body is not to be attained by
weakening the appreciation of military necessities at the very fountain
head of their supply in the administration. This necessary appreciation
can be the result only of personal experience of good and bad through
the formative period of life.
We find, therefore, at the very outset of our inquiry two fundamental
yet opposing elements, neither of which can be eliminated. Nor can they
be reconciled, in the sense of becoming sympathetic. In its proper
manifestation the jealousy between the civil and military spirits is a
healthy symptom. They can be made to work together harmoniously and
efficiently; to complement, not to antagonize each other; provided means
are taken to ensure to each its due relative precedence and weight in
the determination of practical questions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account