Mahan on naval warfare : $b Selections from the writing of Rear Admiral Alfred T. MahanMahan, A. T. (Alfred Thayer)
History
Mahan on naval warfare : $b Selections from the writing of Rear Admiral Alfred T. Mahan
Mahan, A. T. (Alfred Thayer)
Naval art and science; Naval strategy; Sea-power
No man wrestled with the question more vigorously than Nelson; none
found greater exasperation than he did in the too often successful
opposition of the letter to the demands of his impetuous spirit for
co-operation, addressed to men over whom he had not immediate control;
none was more generous in his attitude to subordinates who overrode or
overpassed his own orders, provided he saw in their acts the intelligent
and honest will to forward his purposes. Obedience he certainly
required; but he recognized that, given a capable and zealous man,
better work would usually be had by permitting a certain elasticity of
initiative, provided it was accompanied by accurate knowledge of his
general wishes. These he was always most careful to impart; in nothing
was he more precise or particular. If he allowed large liberty in the
letter, he expected close observance of, nay, rather, participation in,
the spirit of his ideas. He was not tolerant of incapacity, nor would he
for a moment bear willful disregard of his plans. When considerations of
high policy entertained by himself were crossed by Sidney Smith, his
language became peremptory. “_As this is in strict opposition to my
opinion_, which is _never to suffer any one individual Frenchman to quit
Egypt, I strictly charge and command you_ never to give any French ship
or man leave to quit Egypt.” The italics are his own; and he adds again,
as though distrustful still: “You are to put my orders in force, not on
any pretense to permit a single Frenchman to leave Egypt.” The severity
of the tone sufficiently proves his disposition to enforce the strictest
rule, where necessary to control individuals; but a more liberal
reliance upon principle, in preference to rule, was his habit. None, it
may be added, illustrated more copiously than he, when a junior, the
obedience of the spirit and the disobedience of the letter. His practice
was in this consistent in all stages of his career. Unfortunately, the
example may tempt smaller men to follow where their heads are not steady
enough to keep their feet.
Of course, thinking and feeling thus, he gave frequent expression to his
views, and these, coming from a man of his military genius, are often
very illuminative. There is one such that is singularly applicable to
our present purpose, of searching for the underlying principle which
governs the duty and observance of obedience, and determines its
absolute necessity to all military action. “I find few think as I do,
but to obey orders is all perfection. What would my superiors direct,
did they know what is passing under my nose? To serve my King and to
destroy the French I consider as the great order of all, from which
little ones spring, and if one of these little ones militate against it,
I go back to obey the great order.”
14. PREPAREDNESS FOR NAVAL WAR[39]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account