Makers of Modern MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
History
Makers of Modern Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Medicine -- Biography
"In investigating the seats of disease, Morgagni is not content to
record the coincidence of a lesion in an organ with the symptoms
apparently due to disordered function in that organ.
"For the first time almost in medical inquiry, he insists on
examining every organ, as well as the one suspected to be chiefly
implicated; not only so, he marshals with the utmost care, from his
own experience and that of his predecessors, all the instances in
which the symptoms have existed apart from the lesion, or the lesion
apart from the symptoms. He discusses each of these incidents with
severe exactness in the interest of truth, and only after an
exhaustive investigation will he allow the inference either that the
organ referred to is or is not the seat of the disease.
"And in like manner in dealing with causes: a group of symptoms may
be caused by certain organic changes--it may be even probable that
it is so--but, according to Morgagni's method, we must first inquire
into all the lesions of {31} organs which occur in connection with
such symptoms; in the second place, we must know if such lesions
ever occur without the symptoms; and again if such symptoms can be
attributed in any cases to other causes in the absence of such
lesions."
During over sixty years of a long life Morgagni continued to follow
out the idea that he had developed as a boy, and his works contain the
first definite account of pathological lesions and clinical
manifestations that attracted attention.
As a proof of the striking difference between the value of observation
and theory in medicine, it may be said that many hundreds of volumes
containing the most elaborate medical theories were published during
the eighteenth century, and that practically none of these is ever
read now, except for curiosity's sake by some seeker after the quaint
and distant in medicine, while Morgagni's books still contain a
precious fund of information, to which pathologists at least, and not
a few clinicians, turn often with interest and come away always with
profit. They are not infrequently quoted from, and, as we shall see,
have been highly appreciated by some of the best medical authorities
of the present and the immediately preceding generations.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account