Manners and Monuments of Prehistoric PeoplesNadaillac, Jean-François-Albert du Pouget, marquis de
History
Manners and Monuments of Prehistoric Peoples
Nadaillac, Jean-François-Albert du Pouget, marquis de
Archaeology; Prehistoric peoples
It is even more difficult to come to a satisfactory conclusion with
regard to European examples of the practice we have been describing.
Trepanation was certainly practised in the treatment of certain
diseases of the bone, such as osteitis or caries. Professor Parrot
mentions a case worth quoting.30 A few years ago several skeletons were
found at Bray-sur-Seine (Seine-et-Marne) with numerous objects, such as
polished stone hatchets, bone stilettos, shell necklaces and ornaments,
all undoubtedly Neolithic. One of the crania had been trepanned, the
position of the operation showing that its object had been to treat an
osteitis. The operation had succeeded, and the cicatrization of the
bones, both about the wound and in the parts originally affected, shows
that recovery was complete. This is the only example we have of an
operation executed with a view to curing a disease that can actually be
seen, and it enables us to conclude that these men, of whom we know so
little, had some notion of surgery. Were trepanations also practised to
cure epilepsy or to heal mental affections? From the earliest times the
seat of these troubles was always supposed to be the brain, and an
ancient book of medicine recommends as a remedy the scraping of the
outside of the skull.31 In a recent book (“De la Trépanation dans
l’Épilepsie par le Traumatisme du Crâne”), Echeverria mentions several
cases of cure by trepanation when epilepsy had been the result of an
injury. Observation may have led our prehistoric ancestors to discover
this. May we date this custom then from prehistoric times? It is very
difficult to decide with certainty either for or against it.
Of one thing, however, we may be quite certain. The cranial
perforations so much like one another reported from districts so remote
and different in character, cannot be accidental. It is impossible to
attribute to chance the occurrence of injuries of exactly the same size
in crania of totally different origins. Setting aside the Entre-Roches
skull, the antiquity of which does not seem to us sufficiently
established, we find this custom maintained throughout the period
characterized by the use of polished stone weapons and implements, the
erection of megalithic monuments, and the domestication of animals. It
was practised by the men of the cave of _L’Homme Mort_ at the beginning
of the Neolithic period, and was still in use at Moret when metals
began to be known. The discoveries of Dr. Wankel, the excavations of
the tumulus of Guisseny, prove that trepanation was continued
throughout the Bronze age, whilst the Jeuilly and Limet tombs show that
it was not discontinued even in Merovingian times.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account