English essays; English literature -- 20th century; Short stories, English
The 'Acropolis,' a review of literature, science, art, politics, society,
and the drama, is, as every one knows, our leading literary weekly. Its
original promoters decided on its rather eccentric title with a symbolism
now outmoded. The 'Acropolis' was to be impregnable to outside
contributors, and the editor was always to be invisible. All the vile
and secret arts of reclame and puffery were to find no place in its
immaculate pages. One afternoon some time ago a number of gentlemen,
more or less responsible for the production of the 'Acropolis,' were
seated round the fire in the smoking-room of a certain club. For the
last hour they had been discussing with some warmth the merits of signed
or unsigned articles and the reviewing of books. A tall, good-looking
man, who pretended to be unpopular, was advocating the anonymous. 'There
is something so cowardly about a signed article,' he was saying. 'It is
nearly as bad as insulting a man in public, when there is no redress
except to call for the police. And that is ridiculous. If I am slated
by an anonymous writer, it is always in my power to pay no attention,
whereas if the slate is signed, I am obliged to take notice of some kind.
I must either deny the statements, often at a great sacrifice of truth,
or if I assault the writer there is always the risk of his being
physically stronger than I am. No; anonymous attack is the only weapon
for gentlemen.'
'To leave for a moment the subject of anonymity,' said an eminent
novelist, 'I think the great curse of all criticism is that of slating
any book at all. Think of the unfortunate young man or woman first
entering the paths of literature, and the great pain it causes them. You
should encourage them, and not damp their enthusiasm.'
'My dear fellow,' said North, 'I encourage no one, and writers should
never have any feelings at all. They can't have any, or they would not
bore the public by writing.'
The discussion was getting heated when the editor, Rivers, interfered.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account