Medical experts: Investigation of Insanity by JuriesThorne, W. S.
Science
Medical experts: Investigation of Insanity by Juries
Thorne, W. S.
Insanity (Law); Medical jurisprudence; Medicine -- California
large number of medical and lay witnesses were examined, and the result
of the inquiry was a declaration of insanity, and the order that the
accused be taken to Stockton. A short time before this trial took place,
this gentleman made and executed a second deed of one-half of the
remaining property, to his wife. Immediately after he had been declared
insane by the last commission, and before he was taken to Stockton, a
jury was demanded to determine the fact of his restoration to sanity.
This trial was contested by the family, and a large number of medical
witnesses were called, including his family physician and the
Superintendent of the Asylum at Stockton. The testimony of the medical
witnesses was unanimously in favor of his insanity. Numerous witnesses,
among the laity, however, were not wanting whose opinions flatly
contradicted those of learned gentlemen, and the jury returned a verdict
of sanity. A few months subsequent to the latter decision, this
unfortunate gentleman began an action in the District Court to have the
second deed to his wife set aside, upon the ground that he was insane at
the time of executing it. The judgment of the court was, that the deed
be set aside upon the grounds as alleged in the complaint. Mr.
President, we behold the transformation of the caterpillar into the
butterfly and we marvel at the mysterious process of designing nature;
but what a sluggard is nature when compared to the law! The law can
metamorphose a human intellect from health to frenzy and from frenzy to
health by the exercise of its resistless fiat. We read of the Arabian
Knights and of Aladdin's Lamp, but the fantastic evolutions of this
legal romance surpass them all. The same individual in the short space
of two years, without apparent change in his mental state, so far as
could be determined by physicians or friends, is thrice pronounced
insane by as many commissions of lunacy, twice sane by two different
juries and once insane by a District Judge, in order to annul a deed
that was executed just prior to the verdict of a jury that declared him
sane and therefore responsible for his acts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account