How it came that English midwives fell gradually from their high
estate is partly explained by a very public-spirited book (with the
appropriate motto “Non sibi sed aliis”) written by a surgeon in
1736.[21] The writer adverts to the accusations of ignorance then
brought against the midwives, and remarks that “the only method by
which this fatal distemper can be cured, is to put it in the power of
midwomen to qualify themselves thoroughly and at a moderate expense....
To which method of qualifying themselves I doubt not the midwomen will
object, and say that they would readily be at any reasonable expense
and fatigue to be so thoroughly instructed, but it is not in their
power. The midwomen cannot, and the midmen will not instruct them. The
midmen will object and say that the midwomen want both capacity and
strength (instruct them as ye please). To which I reply (_ore rotundo,
plenis buccis_) that it is not want of capacity, docility, strength, or
activity ... which is evident to a demonstration from the successful
practice of women in the Hôtel Dieu at Paris (the best school for
midwifery now in Europe).... Would not any person then be deservedly
laughed at who should assert that our women are not as capable of
performing their office had they the same instruction as the French
women?” This chivalrous surgeon then proposes that regular provision
should be made for proper instruction, and for examinations by two
surgeons (who have lectured to the women), “and six or seven other
persons appointed by His Majesty, because I don’t think it reasonable
that so many people’s bread should depend on the humour or caprice of
two men only;” adding that “If some such scheme was put in execution,
I’m satisfied that in a very few years there would not be an ignorant
midwife in England, and consequently the great agonies most women
suffer at the very sight of a man would be almost entirely prevented,”
and great expense and much life saved.
However, we must suppose that these noble words of protest fell upon
deaf ears, and the midwives, being left in their ignorance, their
practice gradually passed into the hands of the medical men, who had
every advantage of learning at their command.[22]
It is, however, only very recently that men-midwives have been allowed
to attend on royal patients in this country; indeed, I believe that
the Princess Charlotte was the first to establish the precedent, and
that our present Sovereign was the first queen who followed it. In a
very interesting series of papers, by Dr Aveling, recently published
in the _Lancet_,[23] accounts have been given of a number of the royal
midwives whose names have been honourably preserved in history, such as
Alice Dennis, who attended Anne of Denmark, and received a fee of £100
“for her pains and attendance upon the Queen, as of His Highness’s free
gift and reward, without account, imprest, or other charge to be set on
her for the same.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account