Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Religion
Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Medicine -- Religious aspects; Pastoral medicine
‘We have no difficulty in believing that ulcers that have a malignant
aspect may be healed by the hope that comes from a potent suggestion.
We have ourselves known of more than one case in which every clinical
sign of malignant disease of the stomach was present, and in which a
cure was effected by means that could only have derived their potency
from suggestion.’
People who are prepared to accept this _without clearly ascertained
and properly sifted evidence_ will accept anything. They simply
believe what they wish to believe. When one widely advertised ‘case of
spiritual healing’ breaks down on investigation, another is put forward.
Indeed, for the most part they have no idea as to what constitutes
evidence in these matters. In many cases the unsupported statement of
a patient, as to the diagnosis pronounced by a medical man, is calmly
accepted by them as though there were no need of further investigation.
We have heard, perhaps, more than enough of a highly placed dignitary
of the Church who believes (no doubt quite sincerely) that he was cured
of cancer by the ministrations of one of these ‘healers,’ after an
absolute diagnosis as to the existence of an inoperable tumour had been
made by a leading specialist. The repeated denial by the specialist in
question, that he ever supposed the condition which he examined to
be cancerous, makes no difference. The patient continues to announce
as a fact what is almost demonstrably untrue; and his followers will
no doubt continue to accept his statement in preference to first-hand
evidence, so long as this particular cult survives.
But, for those who are not blinded by ignorant credulity, the following
extracts from a letter from Dr. Combe Atthill may be of interest. Dr.
Atthill’s experience could, of course, be paralleled by any medical man
of long practice:
‘Shortly after I retired from practice, some ten years ago, a
well-known clergyman wrote to me, saying that members of his
congregation were being much disturbed by the advent amongst them of
a lady professing herself to be a faith healer, and saying that her
conversion was due to the fact of my having told her that she was
suffering from a dreadful disease, and that her sole hope of cure lay
in the performance of a very dangerous operation. She refused to submit
to this, and instead placed herself in the hands of “the healer,” and
was cured. He concluded by asking me to give him particulars of her
case.
‘I had no recollection of any such patient, but, as the name was given,
I traced her, and found the following particulars recorded in my case
book.
‘I had only seen the lady once in my own house, when she stated that
she was well past middle life, and for more than a year had been
weakened by a well-known condition.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account