Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Religion
Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Medicine -- Religious aspects; Pastoral medicine
‘On my telling her I must examine her she replied that she could not
submit to it that day for sufficient reasons, so I arranged that when
she was in a condition for examination she would let me know, and I
would call on her and examine her. I made no diagnosis, and gave no
opinion as to the nature of the case. I said no word about performing
an operation.
‘Instead of writing to me to call on her, she went to London. No doubt
an examination would have revealed the fact that no disease ever
existed.
‘It is impossible to deal with patients of this class. Their mental
equilibrium is disturbed; they distort what the doctor may say, and not
infrequently invent and circulate statements he never made.’
II. _The Society of Emmanuel_
Special attention has been directed of late to the claims of the
‘Society of Emmanuel.’ This society appears to profess adherence to
the tenets of the Church of England, though, except for Dr. Mylne
(formerly Bishop of Bombay), no well-known churchman, lay or cleric,
seems to be a member of the executive. The names of some ladies of
title are given in the list of the General Committee. The president
and principal ‘healer’ is a Mr. James M. Hickson. The objects of the
society are closely akin to those of other similar societies, except
that they have a distinctly ‘Church’ flavour. For instance:
‘To develop the Divine gifts left to His Church by the Master,
especially the gift of healing by prayer and laying on of hands, with
the object of using these Divine gifts ... for the healing of the body.’
A perusal of its literature reveals the usual pretension to cure and
to have cured any and every disease. Nothing like a tabulated list of
cases treated appears anywhere. The society has now opened a ‘Hospice,’
where free treatment (by prayer and laying on of hands, &c.) is given
by the aforesaid Mr. Hickson.
For some time the _British Medical Journal_, the official organ of the
British Medical Association, called attention to widely advertised
‘cures,’ and asked for information which would make it possible for an
investigation into the true facts to be carried out. The results were
hardly satisfactory. Here are some of the cases:
(1) In the _British Medical Journal_ (May 1, 1909) the following case
is given as recorded in _The Healer_ (the organ of the Society of
Emmanuel):
‘The patient fell and injured the patella, which had previously been
broken four times--two doctors expressed the opinion that he would
never have full use of the knee again. It was very painful and quite
callous (_sic_) at the time of the first treatment by prayer, but in
twenty minutes he was able to bend it without help; the following day
to walk about the house, and after four visits to resume ordinary
duties.’
Inquiries failed to elicit any details which would enable investigation
to be made.
(2) From the _British Medical Journal_ of June 5, 1909:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account