Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Literature, Medieval -- History and criticism; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Medieval
The long reign of sophistic reduced rhetoric to style.[65] That this was
the preoccupation even of the earlier sophistic we may guess from the
derision of the _Phædrus_ and from other references.[66]
And there is also Polus, who has schools of diplasiology and
gnomology and eikonology, and who teaches in them the words of
which Licymnius made him a present; they were to give a polish.
_Phædrus_, 267, Jowett’s translation.
The wider scope demanded by Aristotle’s different conception is
recognized in the traditional fivefold division[67] found in Cicero and
Quintilian. This division, which has such validity as to be essential
for securing the educational values proposed by the ancients, seems to
have been inactive from Quintilian on to the fall of Rome.[68] That the
limitation to style impoverishes rhetoric and impairs even the study of
style itself is evident in the sophistic period and is confirmed in the
medieval.
Incidentally, the focus on style contributed to the confusion of rhetoric
with poetic.[69] Neither being conceived often in its larger aspects of
movement, both being studied habitually for words and sentences, the
distinction between the two was the more easily blurred. Here poetry
had the more to lose. The use of poetic diction to decorate oratory
must have confirmed the tendency to conceive poetic itself as an art of
decoration.
But the main results of giving to style a monopoly are the cultivation
of literary flavor, with conformity to past usage, and the forcing of
figure and rhythm. The style inevitably acquired by those who seek style
is decorative and elaborate. In order to sound literary, the orator
is impelled both to depart from common speech and to force his note.
Devices valuable in revision, to clarify and impress a message, become
artificial in practise and unduly elaborated in theory by being pursued
for themselves.
(1) Literary Allusion and Archaism
The preoccupation that seized any opportunity for “Medics”[70] led to
frequent literary allusions. Allusion is a legitimate, sometimes an
important, means of heightening eloquence. Reviving old associations by
familiar words and rhythms, it helps to suggest a mood or intensify an
appeal.
Who is this that cometh from Domrémy? Who is she in bloody
coronation robes from Rheims? Who is she that cometh with
blackened flesh from walking the furnaces of Rouen? De Quincey,
_Joan of Arc_, last paragraph.
But the sophists used this form of suggestion so incontinently, and often
so conventionally,[71] as to betray an anxiety to sound literary.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account