Meditations on the Essence of Christianity, and on the Religious Questions of the Day.Guizot, François
Religion
Meditations on the Essence of Christianity, and on the Religious Questions of the Day.
Guizot, François
Christianity -- Essence, genius, nature; Philosophy and religion
"The biblical authors," he writes to me, "whose style is most
incorrect, are Ezekiel and Jeremiah. These authors, and
particularly the first, err frequently against grammar and
orthography; they are not merely influenced by the Aramean
dialect, but they disclose grammatical faults capable of being
traced to no source in any of the Semitic dialects. This remark
has also been made by Hebrew grammarians of the middle ages,
and Isaac Abrabanel (towards the close of the 15th century), in
the preface to his commentary upon Ezekiel, does not hesitate
to declare that this prophet was but superficially acquainted
with Hebrew grammar and orthography.
{300}
Nevertheless, neither Jeremiah nor Ezekiel, of whom both are
distinguished by a certain originality of style, unlike that of
any of the other Hebrew writers, is wanting in elegance,
energy, and boldness in images, and they display in the highest
degree their proficiency in the art of composition. The
following are some instances of the grave faults against
grammar to be met with in their writings:--
_Examples of Incorrect Expressions in Ezekiel._
[Transcriber's note: Hebrew text is indicated by "HHHHHH".
Some Latin characters are not exact. See the html version
for the original text.]
HHHHHH (_mischta' hawithem_), "and they worshipped" (viii.
16), a barbarism for HHHHHH (_mischta'hawîm_).
HHHHHH (_we-néschaar ani_), "and I remained" (xi. 8), for
HHHHHH (_wa-ëschaër_) or HHHHHH (_we-nischarti_).
(There are here faults both of orthography and grammar.)
HHHHHH (_ischôth_), "women" (xxiii. 44), for HHHHHH
(_nesché_). HHHHHH (_schib'a_), "his seven burnt
offerings" (xl. 26), for HHHHHH (_scheba'_). In the number
seven the masculine is used instead of the feminine.
HHHHHH (_bi-benôthayikh_), "in that thou buildest" (xvi.
31), instead of HHHHHH (_bi-benotihékh_).
HHHHHH (_be-schoubéni_), "when I returned" (xlvi. 7),
instead of HHHHHH (_be-schoubi_).
HHHHHH (_gabehâ_), "his height was exalted" (xxxi. 5),
instead of HHHHHH (_gabehâ_). The last letter is
_aleph_, for _hé_.
{301}
The Chaldean plural is used in several words, for instance:
HHHHHH (_'hittîn_), "wheat" (iv. 9), for HHHHHH
(_'hittîm_); HHHHHH (_ha-iyyîn_), "the isles," or "the
isles in the sea" (xxvi. 18), instead of HHHHHH
_(ha-iyyim_), an error in both orthography and grammar.
_Examples of Incorrect Expressions in Jeremiah._
HHHHHH (_ôbîdâ_), "I will destroy" (xlvi. 8), for HHHHHH
(_aabîdâ_).
HHHHHH (_nibbetha_), "hast thou prophesied" (xxvi. 9),
instead of HHHHHH (_nibbetha_). The syllable _bé_ has
a _yod_ instead of an _aleph_.
HHHHHH (_athanou_) "we come" (iii. 22), instead of HHHHHH
(_athinou_.).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account