[239] Henderson differs in this account from Home. "Charles," says the latter, "remained on the field of battle till mid-day, giving orders for the relief of the wounded of both armies, for the disposal of his prisoners, and preserving, both from temper and from judgment, every appearance of moderation and humanity," p. 122. [240] Lord Elcho's MS. [241] Maxwell of Kirkconnel's Narrative, p. 55. [242] Maxwell of Kirkconnel's Narrative, p. 57. [243] Maxwell's Narrative, p. 59. [244] Maxwell's Narrative, p. 46. [245] Maxwell of Kirkconnel's Narrative, p. 48. [246] Maxwell, p. 65. [247] History of the Rebellion of 1745 and 1746. Extracted from the Scots' Magazine, p. 99. [248] Maxwell's Narrative, p. 74. [249] Maxwell, p. 76. [250] Jacobite Memoirs. [251] Lord Mahon is decidedly of this opinion. See Vol. iv. Hist. of England, respecting the Jacobites. [252] Lord Elcho's MS. [253] Maxwell, p. 80. [254] Maxwell, p. 112. [255] P. 129. [256] Maxwell, p. 140. [257] P. 147. [258] Chambers. [259] Lord Elcho's Narrative. [260] The estate of Comrie is now in the possession of Sir David Dundas, and the descendant of its former owner, and the Duke's standard-bearer is reduced to be the landlord of the village inn. See Letters of James Duke of Perth, Chancellor of Scotland. Printed for the Camden Society, and edited by Wm. Jerdan, Esq. [261] The battle, according to the newspapers of the day, lasted about half an hour. [262] Maxwell, p. 154. [263] See Lord Elcho's MS. Narrative; which, however, since it is written in a bitter spirit, and varies in many details and in most opinions from Maxwell's, I am not disposed wholly to trust. [264] The traditionary accounts have been collected, in the case of Thos. Drummond, a claimant of the honours and estates of the Earldom of Perth. Newcastle upon Tyne, 1831. I do not vouch for the truth of these anecdotes, but they have an air of probability. [265] Case of Thomas Drummond, p. 18. [266] See case of Thomas Drummond, p. 26. [267] Case, p. 34. Dr. Malcolm had in his book made a different statement; but had contemplated re-publishing his work, with corrections, among which the existence (after 1747) of James Drummond, was to be asserted. [268] For this information, and also for a copy of the case of Thomas Drummond, I am indebted to the kindness of W. E. Aytoun, Esq. [269] In 1816, another appeal, and a fresh claim to the Drummond estates, and to the Earldom of Perth, were brought forward by the descendant of John Drummond, the great-uncle of James, Duke of Perth. The said John Drummond was raised to the dignity of the English peerage in 1685, by James the Second, by the title of Viscount Melfort; in 1686 he was raised to the dignity of Earl of Melfort; and afterwards, following the monarch to St. Germains, was created Duke of Melfort.