Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence — John Shaqi
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defenceMendel, Gregor
Science
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence
Mendel, Gregor
Heredity; Hybridization; Mendel's law; Weldon, Walter Frank Raphael. Mendel's laws of alternative inheritance in peas
[4] See later. Galton gave a simple diagrammatic representation of
his law in _Nature_, 1898, vol. LVII. p. 293.
But already many cases are known to which the rule in any simple
form will not apply. Galton points out that it takes no account of
individual prepotencies. There are, besides, numerous cases in which
on crossing two varieties the character of one variety almost always
appears in each member of the first cross-bred generation. Examples of
these will be familiar to those who have experience in such matters.
The offspring of the Polled Angus cow and the Shorthorn bull is almost
invariably polled or with very small loose “scurs.” Seedlings raised
by crossing _Atropa belladonna_ with the yellow-fruited variety have
without exception the blackish-purple fruits of the type. In several
hairy species when a cross with a glabrous variety is made, the first
cross-bred generation is altogether hairy[5].
[5] These we now recognize as examples of Mendelian ‘dominance.’
Still more numerous are examples in which the characters of one variety
very largely, though not exclusively, predominate in the offspring.
These large classes of exceptions--to go no further--indicate that,
as we might in any case expect, the principle is not of universal
application, and will need various modifications if it is to be
extended to more complex cases of inheritance of varietal characters.
No more useful work can be imagined than a systematic determination of
the precise “law of heredity” in numbers of particular cases.
Until lately the work which Galton accomplished stood almost alone in
this field, but quite recently remarkable additions to our knowledge
of these questions have been made. In the year 1900 Professor de Vries
published a brief account[6] of experiments which he has for several
years been carrying on, giving results of the highest value.
[6] _Comptes Rendus_, March 26, 1900, and _Ber. d. Deutsch. Bot.
Ges._ xviii. 1900, p. 83.
The description is very short, and there are several points as to which
more precise information is necessary both as to details of procedure
and as to statement of results. Nevertheless it is impossible to doubt
that the work as a whole constitutes a marked step forward, and the
full publication which is promised will be awaited with great interest.
The work relates to the course of heredity in cases where definite
varieties differing from each other in some _one_ definite character
are crossed together. The cases are all examples of discontinuous
variation: that is to say, cases in which actual intermediates between
the parent forms are not usually produced on crossing[7]. It is shown
that the subsequent posterity obtained by self-fertilising these
cross-breds or hybrids, or by breeding them with each other, break up
into the original parent forms according to fixed numerical rule.
[7] This conception of discontinuity is of course pre-Mendelian.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account