Mendel's principles of heredity: A defenceMendel, Gregor
Science
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence
Mendel, Gregor
Heredity; Hybridization; Mendel's law; Weldon, Walter Frank Raphael. Mendel's laws of alternative inheritance in peas
Professor Weldon refers to both Crampe and von Guaita, whose results
show an essential harmony in the fact that both found _albino_ an
obvious recessive, pure almost without exception, while the coloured
forms show various phenomena of dominance. Both found heterozygous
colour-types. He then searches for something that looks like a
contradiction. Of this there is no lack in the works of Johann von
Fischer (11)--an authority of a very different character--whom he
quotes in the following few words:
“In both rats and mice von Fischer says that piebald rats crossed
with albino varieties of their species, give piebald young if the
father only is piebald, white young if the mother only is piebald.”
But this is doing small justice to the completeness of Johann von
Fischer’s statement, which is indeed a proposition of much more amazing
import.
That investigator in fact began by a study of the cross between the
albino Ferret and the Polecat, as a means of testing whether they were
two species or merely varieties. The cross, he found, was in colour and
form a blend of the parental types. Therefore, he declares, the Ferret
and the Polecat are two distinct species, because, “as everybody ought
to know,”
“_The result of a cross between albino and normal [of one species] is
always a constant one, namely an offspring like the father at least
in colour_[135],”
[135] “Das Resultat einer Kreuzung zwischen Albino- und Normal-form
ist stets, also, constant, ein dem Vater mindestens in der Färbung
gleiches Junge.” This law is predicated for the case in which both
parents belong to the same species.
whereas in _crosses_ (between species) this is _not_ the case.
And again, after reciting that the Ferret-Polecat crosses gave
intermediates, he states:
“But all this is _not_ the case in crosses between albinos and normal
animals within the species, in which always and without any exception
the young resemble the father in colour[136].”
[136] “Dieses Alles ist aber _nie_ der Fall bei Kreuzungen unter
Leucismen und normalen Thieren innerhalb der Species, bei denen
_stets und ohne jede Ausnahme die Jungen in Färbung dem Vater
gleichen_.”
These are admirable illustrations of what is meant by a “_universal_”
proposition. But von Fischer doesn’t stop here. He proceeds to
give a collection of evidence in proof of this truth which he says
“ought to be known to everyone.” He has observed the fact in regard
to albino mole, albino shrew (_Sorex araneus_), melanic squirrel
(_Sciurus vulgaris_), albino ground-squirrel (_Hypudaeus terrestris_),
albino hamster, albino rats, albino mice, piebald (grey-and-white or
black-and-white) mice and rats, partially albino sparrow, and we are
even presented with two cases in Man. No single exception was known to
von Fischer[137].
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account