Mendel's principles of heredity: A defenceMendel, Gregor
Science
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence
Mendel, Gregor
Heredity; Hybridization; Mendel's law; Weldon, Walter Frank Raphael. Mendel's laws of alternative inheritance in peas
One may naturally ask, How can these results be brought into harmony
with the facts of hybridisation hitherto known; and, if all this is
true, how is it that others who have carefully studied the phenomena
of hybridisation have not long ago perceived this law? The answer to
this question is given by Mendel at some length, and it is, I think,
satisfactory. He admits from the first that there are undoubtedly cases
of hybrids and cross-breds which maintain themselves pure and do not
break up. Such examples are plainly outside the scope of his law. Next
he points out, what to anyone who has rightly comprehended the nature
of discontinuity in variation is well known, that the variations in
_each_ character must be _separately_ regarded. In most experiments in
crossing, forms are taken which differ from each other in a multitude
of characters--some continuous, others discontinuous, some capable of
blending with their contraries, while others are not. The observer on
attempting to perceive any regularity is confused by the complications
thus introduced. Mendel’s law, as he fairly says, could only appear in
such cases by the use of overwhelming numbers, which are beyond the
possibilities of practical experiment. Lastly, no previous observer had
applied a strict statistical method.
Both these answers should be acceptable to those who have studied the
facts of variation and have appreciated the nature of Species in the
light of those facts. That different species should follow different
laws, and that the same law should not apply to all characters alike,
is exactly what we have every right to expect. It will also be
remembered that the principle is only explicitly declared to apply to
discontinuous characters[11]. As stated also it can only be true where
reciprocal crossings lead to the same result. Moreover, it can only be
tested when there is no sensible diminution in fertility on crossing.
[11] See later.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account